Submitted: 10 March 2025
Accepted: 5 July 2025
Published online: 7 October, TAPS 2025, 10(4), 55-62
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-4/OA3690

Aaron Tigor Sihombing^1,2, Antonia Kartika^3,4 & Anglita Yantisetiasti^2,5

¹Department of Surgery, Division of Urology, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, Indonesia; ²Hasan Sadikin General Hospital, Bandung, Indonesia; ³National Eye Center-Cicendo Eye Hospital, Bandung, Indonesia; ⁴Department of Ophthalmology, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, Indonesia; ⁵Department of Anatomical Pathology, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Padjadjaran, Bandung, Indonesia

Abstract

Introduction: Music preferences have been linked to personality traits, which in turn may influence career choices. This study explores the potential relationship between music genre preferences and medical specialty selections among residents at Padjadjaran University, Indonesia.

Methods: A cross-sectional survey was conducted among all residents trained in urology, ophthalmology, and anatomic pathology. Data collected included demographic characteristics, music genre preferences, and work habits related to music. Independent t-tests are used when data are normally distributed, whereas Kruskal-Wallis tests are used when data are not normally distributed.

Results: The study included 125 residents (19 pathology anatomy, 33 urology, 73 ophthalmology). Pop was the most preferred music genre across all specialties (48% in urology, 61% in ophthalmology, 52% in pathology anatomy). However, secondary preferences varied: rock (21%) was the second most popular among urology residents, jazz (10.9%) and indie (10.9%) among ophthalmology residents, and classical music (26%) among pathology anatomy residents. Demographic differences were noted, with pathology anatomy residents being older and urology residents having a higher proportion of males. Ethnic distribution was relatively consistent across specialties, primarily mixed ethnicity, Sundanese, and Javanese.

Conclusion: While pop music was the predominant preference across all specialties, secondary music preferences varied, potentially reflecting different personality traits associated with each specialty. The study’s findings are limited by its single-institution sample and cross-sectional design, necessitating further research with larger, more diverse populations to explore the underlying mechanisms linking music preferences to medical specialisation choices.

Keywords:           Music Preferences, Medical Specialty Selection, Personality Traits

Practice Highlights

• Personality traits could predict specialty preferences among medical students.
• Music genre preferences are associated with personality traits, thus are drawn to particular type of music.
• Residents in different specialties distributed music genres differently.

I. INTRODUCTION

The notion that music genres reflect and influence personality traits is a topic of much debate and interest. Research has shown a correlation between musical preferences and personality traits, with certain genres being associated with specific characteristics (Andrews et al., 2022; Wang et al., 2024). For example, music in slow tempo and music in minor keys were significantly predicted by emotional stability and optimism, whereas music in fast tempo and music in major keys was significantly predicted by openness to experiences, introversion, and gender (Dobrota & Reić, 2014; Upadhyay et al., 2017). Some evidence suggests that individuals drawn to certain music genres may exhibit personality profiles that align with specific career paths. For instance, individuals who prefer classical music tend to score higher in openness and introversion—traits associated with analytical or solitary professions—while those who enjoy rock or pop may display extraversion and sensation-seeking behaviors, often linked to high-energy or interactive professions (Rentfrow & Gosling, 2003; Schäfer & Mehlhorn, 2017). Moreover, individuals with high levels of achievement tend to prefer music that reflects their professional identity, indicating a potential association between occupational roles and musical preferences (Knox & McDonald, 2017).

Similarly, in the field of medicine, there is a growing interest in understanding how personality traits may influence medical residency preferences. Studies suggest that certain personality types may be drawn to specific medical specialties, and this alignment could impact their satisfaction and performance within that field. This intersection of music, personality, and medical career choices highlights the complex ways in which our preferences and personalities shape and reflect our identities and professional paths.

Culture and environment have a profound effect on a person’s personality (Smaldino et al., 2019; Triandis & Suh, 2002). Culture provides a framework within which individuals develop beliefs, values, and behaviours that are in harmony with their societal norms. It shapes personality through language, customs, and social norms, which guide an individual’s actions and interactions. Environment, encompassing family dynamics, social relationships, and educational experiences, also plays a pivotal role in molding personality traits. As individuals navigate through different environmental contexts, their personalities adapt and evolve, reflecting the dynamic interplay between their innate dispositions and external influences. This complex interconnection suggests that personality is not a static entity but a fluid construct that changes over time, influenced by the cultural and environmental landscapes we inhabit.

Indonesia’s rich of cultures is indeed a testament to its diversity, with over 300 ethnic groups calling it home. This multicultural environment offers a unique blend of traditions, languages, and beliefs, which can significantly shape an individual’s personality. Exposure to diverse cultural practices and values can foster open-mindedness, adaptability, and a complex worldview. Research suggests that multicultural experiences can enhance creativity, reduce stereotypes, and provide a broader perspective on life. Moreover, individuals who navigate multiple cultures may develop a multicultural identity, integrating different cultural influences into their personal identity, which can contribute to their overall well-being and social harmony.

The exploration of a potential correlation between musical preferences and medical specialty choice in Indonesia is indeed a fascinating subject. Since music has been noted to affect personality, which in turn influences the choice of medical specialisation, Indonesia is a multicultural country, and this correlation is intriguing. As a result, this study aims to determine if there is a distribution difference between music genre preferences and healthcare specialisations in Indonesia.

II. METHODS

This research employed a cross-sectional study design, with total sampling of all Padjadjaran University resident utilising a comprehensive survey administered to all residents. The study population comprised residents specialising in three distinct medical disciplines: urology, ophthalmology, and anatomic pathology. All residents in urology, ophthalmology, and anatomic pathology were eligible to be included. Exclusion criteria included incomplete responses or refusal to provide consent. This selection allowed for a comparative analysis across specialties with varying degrees of procedural and cognitive demands. In this study we utilised total sampling, all eligible residents during the study period were invited to participate. The survey instrument was designed to collect a range of demographic and preference-based data. Participants were asked to provide information regarding their age, current year of residency training, and their preferred music genres. Crucially, the survey also explored the residents’ work habits related to music, specifically inquiring whether they typically worked with or without background music and their preferred music genre. The survey also collected information on spouse employment status, which was divided into two groups: physicians and non-physicians.

Statistical analysis was performed to assess the difference between groups within the collected data. The independent t-test was employed to analyse continuous data that demonstrated a normal distribution. For continuous data that did not meet the assumptions of normality, the non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis test was utilised. In all statistical analyses, a significance level (p-value) of 0.05 was established as the threshold for statistical significance, indicating a 5% risk of concluding a relationship exists when it does not. All participants have given informed consent before any data were collected.

III. RESULTS

A total of 125 residents participated in this study. Nineteen pathology anatomy residents, 33 urology resident and 73 ophthalmology residents were included. The descriptive statistic of age and sex are presented in Table 1. Marital status and ethnicity are presented in Appendix 1.

		Pathology Anatomy (n = 19)	Urology (n = 33)	Ophthalmology (n = 73)	p-value
Age
	Mean ± SD	33.16 ± 3.11	30.09 ± 2.11	30.51 ± 2.55	0.002*
	Median (Range)	34.00 (29-39)	30.00 (27-37)	30.00 (26-36)
Sex
	Male	4 (21.1%)	26 (79.8%)	22 (30.1%)	<0.01
	Female	15 (78.9%)	7 (21.2%)	51 (69.9%)

*Kruskal Wallis Test

Table 1. Age, sex, ethnicity and marital status of the residents

In male resident population, distribution between married and not married is quite equal between specialty (Figure 1). In urology, married male residents is 58%, while it is 68% and 50% in ophthalmology and pathology, respectively. There is sharp difference in female urology resident compared to other specialties. There are only 14% female urology residents who is married, while in ophthalmology and pathology is 63% and 67%, respectively.

Figure 1. Marital status proportion in male (A) and female (B) residents

Figure 2. Proportion of married residents with physician spouse

In urology, 81% of residents also married to physicians, while it is only 55% in ophthalmology and 42% in pathology (Figure 2).

Most residents in urology (69.70%) and pathology (73.68%) reported that they were listening to musical background while working (Figure 3). While only 38.36% in ophthalmology that worked with musical background.

Figure 3. Comparison between residents working with musical background and those without

Figure 4. Residents’ music genre preference (in percentage)

IV. DISCUSSION

This study explored the relationship between music genre preferences and medical specialty selections among residents at Padjadjaran University. There is a higher median age among pathology anatomy residents than among urology and ophthalmology residents, and there is a greater proportion of males in the urology department (Table 1). In spite of this, all residents from the three departments belong to the same generation (Juekiewicz, 2023). As residents in the same generation (generation Y), they are influenced by similar external influences, values, and ethical principles which influence their music genre preferences (Juekiewicz, 2023; Krumhansl, 2017).

Given that Indonesia is composed of multiple ethnic groups, and ethnicity could influence music genre preference, we found that the top three ethnic groups that reside in the three departments are somewhat similar, namely mixed ethnicity, Sundanese, and Javanese (Table 1). This percentage ranking differs from that of the Badan Pusat Statistik (BPS), which indicates that the top three groups by population are Java (40.22%), Sundanese (15.5%), and Batak (3.58%) (Badan Pusat Statistik [BPS], 2010).

Since music serves as a connection function between people, we evaluate the marital status of the residents (Bamford et al., 2024). In urology, 52% of residents are married, while in pathology and anatomy, 37% and 36% are married, respectively (Table 1). While females comprise only 21% of urology residents, the majority of them are unmarried (86%), which is compared to only 33% and 37% of female pathology anatomy and ophthalmology residents who are unmarried, respectively (Figure 1).

Eighty-one percent of urology residents are married to a physician compared to 55% of ophthalmology residents and 42% of pathology anatomy residents (Figure 2). Study by Dutta RR, et all showed that only 26.1% of physician married with physician (Dutta et al., 2024). However, the study did not compare the percentage of physicians who are married to other physicians in each specialty.

Compared with urology residents (69.7%) and pathology anatomy residents (73.68%), only 38.36% of ophthalmology residents listen to music while working (Figure 3).

Pop genre is the most preferred genre among three groups of residents, comprising 48% of residents in the urology and 61% of residents in the ophthalmology groups, as well as 52% of residents in the pathology anatomy groups (Figure 4). This finding is similar to a study by Krumhansl that the pop genre is the most preferred genre for individuals born between 1940 and 1999 (Krumhansl, 2017). However, the second most preferred genre among urology residents is rock (21%), while jazz (10.9%) and indie (10.9%) are the second most preferred genres in ophthalmology, and classical music (26%) is the second most preferred genre in pathology anatomy. The difference in genre music preference can also be observed in the third to last rank on the list (Figure 4).

The variation in secondary music genre preferences among specialties may be partially explained by psychological theories of personality, particularly the Five-Factor Model (FFM), which posits five broad domains of personality: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism. Prior research has shown that individuals who prefer classical music tend to score high in openness and introversion—traits often linked to reflective and analytical disciplines such as pathology. In contrast, rock and pop fans tend to exhibit higher levels of extraversion and openness to experience, traits more commonly observed in high-intensity, procedurally driven fields like urology (Rentfrow & Gosling, 2003; Schäfer & Mehlhorn, 2017). However, in our study, most residents prefer pop music.

From a sociological perspective, medical specialties may be seen as “occupational subcultures” (Becker, 1963), each with distinct values, stress profiles, and interaction patterns. These subcultures attract individuals whose identities align with the implicit norms of the field (Light, 1979), potentially explaining the alignment between music preference and specialty. For example, the high-paced, team-intensive nature of urology might attract residents who identify with more energetic and expressive music like rock. Conversely, fields like pathology, which involve solitary analysis, may appeal to those who appreciate structured and introspective genres like classical music.

This study has several limitations that affect generalisability of the findings. While the study used a total sample of residents from three departments, the number of residents from each specialty varies, with 19 respondents from pathology anatomy, 33 respondents from urology, and 73 respondents from ophthalmology. In addition, the study’s sample was drawn exclusively from residents of one university.

Despite its limitations, this study presents several strengths that contribute to its value. The study explores a unique and interesting relationship between music genre preferences and medical specialty selection, particularly within the Indonesian cultural context. This area is relatively understudied and by focusing on medical residents, a specific population facing unique career pressures, the research addresses a relevant and understudied group. Furthermore, we acknowledgment of Indonesia’s diverse cultural influences, highlighting the potential impact of environment on both musical tastes and professional choices. We hope that this study will open avenues for further research and raising awareness about the potential influence of external factors like music on medical professionals.

V. CONCLUSION

This cross-sectional study explored the relationship between music genre preferences and medical specialty selections among residents at Padjadjaran University in Indonesia. While the study revealed variations in music preferences distribution across different specialties, pop being the most favored genre and different preference in second to last rank.

We found that there are differences in demographic distributions, particularly age and gender, among the resident groups, it is important to acknowledge the limitations of the study’s design. The use of a single-institution sample and the cross-sectional methodology limit the generalisability of the findings and preclude the establishment of causal relationships. Nevertheless, the study offers a preliminary investigation into the potential interplay between musical tastes and career choices within the medical field, raising intriguing questions for future research.

Further studies with larger and more diverse samples, are needed to expand upon these findings, and to explore the underlying mechanisms that might link music preferences to medical specialisation.

Notes on Contributors

ATS contributed to the conceptualisation, data curation, methodology, formal analysis, project administration, validation, investigation, funding acquisition, resources, visualisation, software, supervision, writing of the original draft, review and editing.

AK contributed to the methodology, formal analysis, resources, visualisation, software, supervision, writing of the original draft, review and editing.

AY contributed to the investigation, visualisation, software, supervision, writing of the original draft, review and editing.

Ethical Approval

This study was performed under the ethical approval from Hasan Sadikin Hospital Ethical Committee (Approval Number: DP.04.03/D.XXIV.16/14527/2024). This study is in line with the 1964 Declaration of Helsinki and existing ethical standards.

Data Availability

The data supporting this study are available upon reasonable request to Corresponding Author.

Funding

The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Declaration of Interest

The authors declare no relevant financial or non-financial competing interest from any party.

References

Andrews, C., Gardiner, K., Jain, T. K., Olomi, Y., & North, A. C. (2022). Culture, personal values, personality, uses of music, and musical taste. Psychology of Aesthetics, Creativity, and the Arts, 16(3), 468–486. https://doi.org/10.1037/aca0000318

Badan Pusat Statistik. (2010). Kewarganegaraan, suku bangsa, agama, dan bahasa sehari-hari penduduk Indonesia (Ch. 3, Komposisi penduduk, p. 9). Badan Pusat Statistik. https://www.bps.go.id/id/publication/2012/05/23/55eca38b7fe0830834605b35/kewarganegaraan-suku-bangsa-agama-dan-bahasa-sehari-hari-penduduk-indonesia.html

Bamford, J. S., Vigl, J., Hämäläinen, M., & Saarikallio, S. H. (2024). Love songs and serenades: A theoretical review of music and romantic relationships. Frontiers in Psychology, 15, 1302548. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1302548

Becker, H. S. (1963). Outsiders: Studies in the sociology of deviance. Free Press.

Dobrota, S., & Reić, E. I. (2014). The relationship between music preferences of different mode and tempo and personality traits – Implications for music pedagogy. Music Education Research, 17(2), 234–247. https://doi.org/10.1080/14613808.2014.933790

Dutta, R. R., Wu, A. T., Picton, B., Shah, S., Chernyak, M., Bauer, K., Solomon, S., Chang, J., Nguyen, B., Jiang, M., & Hurria, A. (2024). Physician marriage survey reveals sex and specialty differences in marital satisfaction factors. Scientific Reports, 14(1), 5159. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-55437-3

Jurkiewicz, C. L. (2023). Age diversity and generational ethics. In L. C. Becker & C. B. Becker (Eds.), Encyclopedia of ethics (pp. 54–62). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-22767-8

Knox, D., & MacDonald, R. (2016). Broadcasting personalities: The relationship between occupation and music preferences in the BBC radio programme Desert Island Discs. Psychology of Music, 45(5), 645–664. https://doi.org/10.1177/0305735616670497

Krumhansl, C. L. (2017). Listening niches across a century of popular music. Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 431. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00431

Light, D. W. (1979). Becoming psychiatrists: The professional transformation of self. W. W. Norton & Company.

Rentfrow, P. J., & Gosling, S. D. (2003). The do re mi’s of everyday life: The structure and personality correlates of music preferences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84(6), 1236–1256. https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.84.6.1236

Schäfer, T., & Mehlhorn, C. (2017). Can personality traits predict musical style preferences? A meta-analysis. Personality and Individual Differences, 116, 265–273. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2017.04.061

Smaldino, P. E., Lukaszewski, A., von Rueden, C., & Gurven, M. (2019). Niche diversity can explain cross-cultural differences in personality structure. Nature Human Behaviour, 3, 1276–1283. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-019-0730-3

Triandis, H. C., & Suh, E. M. (2002). Cultural influences on personality. Annual Review of Psychology, 53, 133–160. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.psych.53.100901.135200

Upadhyay, D. K., Shukla, R., Tripathi, V. N., & Agrawal, M. (2017). Exploring the nature of music engagement and its relation to personality among young adults. International Journal of Adolescence and Youth, 22(4), 484–496. https://doi.org/10.1080/02673843.2016.1245150

Wang, Y., Qu, W., & Ge, Y. (2024). Relationship between personality and music preference: Psychometric adaptation of the music preference scales in a Chinese sample. Musicae Scientiae, 29(1), 109-130. https://doi.org/10.1177/10298649241287072

*Aaron Tigor Sihombing
Jl. Raya Jatinangor, Cikeruh, Kec. Jatinangor,
Kabupaten Sumedang, Jawa Barat 45363
+62 813-2132-9126
Email: aarontigor@gmail.com

Submitted: 11 February 2025
Accepted: 11 July 2025
Published online: 7 October, TAPS 2025, 10(4), 97-99
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-4/II3669

Suryanti Chan¹, Hamzah Hamzah² & Insan Sosiawan Tunru³

¹Department of Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, Universitas Dian Nuswantoro, Indonesia; ²Airlangga Teaching Hospital, Airlangga University, Indonesia; ³Faculty of Medicine, University Yarsi, Indonesia

I. INTRODUCTION

Medical education is a cornerstone of effective healthcare delivery, directly shaping professionals responsible for addressing the complex and evolving needs of patients, families, and communities. Over the last few decades, medical education has undergone significant transformations due to global trends that have influenced curricula structures, learning methodologies, and competency requirements for healthcare professionals. These shifts reflect broader societal, technological, and policy changes, necessitating adaptable and forward-thinking medical education systems.

One key driver of change is globalisation, fostering interconnected healthcare systems and necessitating curricula that emphasise global health perspectives, cultural competence, and cross-disciplinary collaboration.

Additionally, technological advancements, such as simulation-based learning, virtual reality (VR), augmented reality (AR), and telemedicine training, have revolutionised medical education, improving accessibility and enhancing learning experiences.

The increasing importance of accreditation and quality assurance frameworks ensures standardisation in medical education across regions, promoting transparency and continuous improvement (Bedoll et al., 2021). Simultaneously, the shift towards outcome-based education (OBE) prioritise competency-driven frameworks over traditional content-heavy curricula, aligning medical training with healthcare needs. Furthermore, cultural and contextual adaptations are crucial in tailoring curricula to regional healthcare priorities while maintaining global standards.

This paper examines how these international trends, globalisation, technological advancements, accreditation, outcome-based education, and cultural contextualisation, are shaping the future of medical education and influencing curricula to remain responsive to evolving healthcare demands.

II. APPROACH TO SYNTHESIS

Drawing on peer-reviewed articles, academic texts, and authoritative reports published over the past decade, this paper explores key international trends influencing medical education curricula. Sources were identified through a purposive review of major databases, such as PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science, using keywords including “medical education curriculum,” “globalisation,” “technological change in education,” and “outcome-based education.” Selection was guided by relevance, conceptual contribution, and alignment with contemporary educational discourse. Through interpretive synthesis, the emerging themes were organised to highlight the evolving priorities and challenges in curriculum development across diverse global settings.

III. GLOBAL TRENDS SHAPING MEDICAL EDUCATION

Synthesising insights from the existing literature, several key themes emerge, including globalisation, technological advancement, accreditation and quality assurance, and the shift toward outcome-based education, each significantly shaping curriculum design in medical education.

A. Globalisation and Medical Education

Globalisation necessitates the integration of global health perspectives in medical curricula, enhancing students’ cultural competence, global awareness, and adaptability in diverse clinical settings. Imafuku et al. (2021) report that international electives and exposure to various healthcare systems foster a broader understanding of global health challenges. Rukadikar et al. (2022) emphasise embedding cultural competence longitudinally rather than as isolated modules. However, integrating global content can be hampered by linguistic, ethical, and logistical barriers, particularly in low-resource regions. There is also a risk of curricular homogenisation that overlooks local relevance. Initiatives such as the ASEAN Medical Schools Network attempt to address this tension by fostering regional collaboration while maintaining context-sensitive design. Ultimately, globalisation challenges medical educators to balance international standards with localised priorities, cultivating graduates who are both globally minded and locally responsive.

B. Technological Advancements

The digital transformation of medical education, catalysed by the COVID-19 pandemic, has reshaped how knowledge and clinical skills are imparted. Simulation-based learning, virtual patients, high-fidelity manikins, and telemedicine platforms offer realistic, risk-free environments for students to practise complex procedures (Castro et al., 2021). Virtual and augmented reality hold immense promise, especially in underserved areas where traditional clinical exposure is limited (Li et al., 2024). Nevertheless, adoption remains uneven. Barriers such as digital illiteracy, inadequate infrastructure, and resistance to change among faculty hinder optimal implementation. Furthermore, technological integration demands a pedagogical shift towards student-centred, self-directed learning models that not all institutions are prepared to adopt. Addressing these challenges requires systemic investment in digital infrastructure, faculty development, and curriculum redesign to fully harness the potential of educational technology.

C. Accreditation and Quality Assurance

Global accreditation standards, such as those set by the WFME, aim to enhance comparability and mobility of medical graduates by ensuring a baseline of quality and accountability (Bedoll et al., 2021). These frameworks advocate for continuous self-evaluation, peer review, and outcome monitoring. However, rigid adherence to international benchmarks may marginalise unique local needs and strain under-resourced institutions. For example, some Southeast Asian medical schools struggle to meet standards due to shortages in qualified faculty, simulation resources, or research infrastructure. Regional mechanisms like the ASEAN-QA (Asian University Network-Quality Assurance) Framework provide a more flexible model, supporting capacity-building and mutual recognition of quality. Moving forward, accreditation should not be seen solely as a compliance mechanism but as a catalyst for meaningful institutional improvement rooted in contextual realities.

D. Outcome-Based Education

OBE represents a fundamental paradigm shift, placing student competencies at the heart of curriculum design and assessment. Instead of focusing on the amount of content delivered, OBE emphasises the achievement of predefined clinical, ethical, and interpersonal outcomes. The model supports accountability and alignment between educational outcomes and healthcare needs. Ten Cate advocates for the use of Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) to operationalise OBE, offering a structured way to assess readiness for clinical practice. However, the practical implementation of OBE remains challenging. Many institutions lack robust tools for assessing soft skills, professional attitudes, and interprofessional collaboration. Furthermore, faculty may be unfamiliar with the principles of formative, feedback-oriented assessment that OBE requires. Successful implementation demands long-term commitment to faculty development, curriculum mapping, and resource allocation, as well as a cultural shift toward continuous quality improvement.

IV. CONCLUSION

The evolution of medical education is shaped by globalisation, technological advancements, accreditation, cultural adaptation, and outcome-based education. These trends emphasise the need for medical curricula that are adaptable, inclusive, and aligned with global healthcare challenges. Moving forward, medical education must remain dynamic and forward-thinking to prepare graduates for both current and future healthcare landscapes.

Notes on Contributors

Suryanti Chan (SC) contributed to the study design, data collection, and manuscript writing. She was responsible for analysing the findings and drafting the discussion.

Hamzah Hamzah (HH) contributed to the study design, literature review, and manuscript revision. He provided insights on the impact of international trends on medical education curriculum, particularly from the perspective of clinical training and healthcare service management in teaching hospitals.

Insan Sosiawan Tunru (IST) contributed to the study design, literature review, and manuscript revision. He provided insights on the impact of international trends on medical education curriculum, particularly from the perspective of accreditation regulation in Indonesia.

Ethical Approval

This manuscript is a literature review based on existing published studies and does not involve any original data collection or interaction with human participants.

Acknowledgement

Authors would like to express their deepest gratitude and appreciation to Prof. Ir Edi Noersasongko, M.Kom, Prof. Pulung Nurtantio Andono, S.T., M.Kom, Dr. Abdul Syukur, M.M, Dr. Hendriani Selina, Sp. A (K), MARS which has supported during this review.

Funding

This study did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Declaration of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest related to this study.

References

Bedoll, D., Van Zanten, M., & McKinley, D. (2021). Global trends in medical education accreditation. Human Resources for Health, 19(70), 1­­–15. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12960-021-00588-x

Castro, M. R. H., Calthorpe, L. M., Fogh, S. E., McAllister, S., Johnson, C. L., Isaacs, E. D., Ishizaki, A., Kozas, A., Lo, D., Rennke, S., Davis, J., & Chang, A. (2021). Lessons from learners: Adapting medical student education during and post COVID-19. Academic Medicine, 96(12), 1671–1679. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000004148

Imafuku, R., Saiki, T., Hayakawa, K., Sakashita, K., & Suzuki, Y. (2021). Rewarding journeys: Exploring medical students’ learning experiences in international electives. Medical Education Online, 26(1), 1913784. https://doi.org/10.1080/10872981.2021.1913784

Li, X., Elnagar, D., Song, G., & Ghannam, R. (2024). Advancing medical education using virtual and augmented reality in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic and critical review. Virtual Worlds, 3(3), 384–403. https://doi.org/10.3390/virtualworlds3030021

Rukadikar, C., Mali, S., Bajpai, R., Rukadikar, A., & Singh, A. K. (2022). A review on cultural competency in medical education. Journal of Family Medicine and Primary Care, 11(8), 4319–4329. https://doi.org/10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_2503_21

*Suryanti Chan
MD, MPH, MMed, PhD (Health Sciences), FIHFAA
Universitas Dian Nuswantoro,
Pendrikan Kidul Number 184,
Semarang, Central Java Province, Indonesia
(62)851-011-56248
Email: suryanti83@yahoo.com

Submitted: 11 January 2025
Accepted: 11 August 2025
Published online: 7 October, TAPS 2025, 10(4), 77-80
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-4/SC3818

Yassar Alamri

Department of Medicine, University of Otago, Christchurch, New Zealand

Abstract

Introduction: Response rates to surveys of medical students and junior doctors have not previously been explicitly examined. Reasons for the observed response rates have not been scrutinised.  The aims of the present study were to establish an expected response rate to electronic survey among medical students and junior doctors, and to explore reasons behind non-response.

Methods: A follow-up online survey was sent to 93 medical students and junior doctors. The primary method for participants to complete the survey was via the Internet using a well-known and established survey tool. Descriptive and inferential statistics were used to assess response rates and reasons for non-response.

Results: Out of 93 invited medical students and junior doctors, 47 returned the follow-up survey (response rate = 50.5%). The main reasons for non-response were: there were too many surveys (74.4%), lack of time (25.5%), and the original survey being too long (10.6%).

Conclusion: We found a mediocre response rate (50.5%) to electronic surveys by medical students and junior doctors included in this study. Several factors that may impede response to surveys (survey-related, and participant-related) have been identified, and these may be specifically targeted to improve survey response rates.

Keywords:           Medical Student, Survey, Response Rate, Research, Methodology

I. INTRODUCTION

Surveys offer an important method of collecting quantitative data from physicians and medical students on various aspects of medical and clinical research. The ease and convenience of online and web-based surveys (compared with telephone or face-to-face interviews) should theoretically enhance response rates. However, the ideal method of surveying the medical workforce (which would yield a high rate of and representative responses) is yet to be identified.

Physicians have traditionally been reported to have poor response rates to surveys in general. Studies that have specifically assessed response rates to surveys among physicians revealed overall rates of 35–50% (Cunningham et al., 2015). Response rates to surveys and reasons for non-response by medical students and junior doctors have seldom been specifically examined. Previous response rates to the National Physician Survey in Canada reported response rates of approximately 28–35% by medical students and junior doctors (Grava-Gubins & Scott, 2008), although these data are almost two decades old now.

Several reasons for non-response emerge from reviewing the pertinent literature; these can be divided into: survey-factors, and respondent-factors. Survey-factors include the length of the questionnaire (Grava-Gubins & Scott, 2008), perceived interest in and sensitivity of the surveyed topic (Cunningham et al., 2015), and the mode of survey delivery (i.e., electronic, telephone or face-to-face) (Grava-Gubins & Scott, 2008; Weaver et al., 2019). Several incentives have been instigated in order to improve response rates by addressing some of these survey-factors, including utilising electronic surveys that can be completed in more than one setting (at the participants’ convenience)(Weaver et al., 2019), monetary gifts or “educational credit” for participation (Grava-Gubins & Scott, 2008; Viera & Edwards, 2012), and employing internal “buy in” from a respected member of the intended sample (e.g., senior clinician or head of department) (Akl et al., 2011). Respondent-factors for non-response include lack of time, demographic differences, and the specialty of the respondent.

The aims of the present study were to establish an expected response rate to electronic survey among medical students and junior doctors, and to explore reasons behind non-response. No previous study has focused on medical students and junior doctors (i.e., junior medical workforce); therefore, addressing these issues would help fill several gaps in our knowledge.

II. METHODS

A. Study Setting

A previous study (Alamri et al, in press) invited all medical students at the University of Otago, and junior doctors at the Christchurch Hospital (both in Christchurch, New Zealand), to complete an electronic ‘index questionnaire’ on their research activities. The overall response rate of the original survey was 36% despite employing an online survey, several reminders and monetary gift vouchers.

B. Study Participants and Instrument

For the present study, eligible participants were medical student and junior doctor who had started the ‘index questionnaire’, but never completed it. The identified ‘non-responders’ were then invited to a secondary follow-up survey which was sent after the allotted time-period for the index questionnaire had lapsed (August–September 2018).

The follow-up survey was intentionally designed to be very brief, and based upon previous similar surveys (Cunningham et al., 2015). It only included four questions: participant age and sex, current career, and “what were the reasons for not completing [the index questionnaire]?”.

C. Statistical Analysis

Descriptive statistics (means ± standard deviations, and percentages) were used to analyse most of the data. Comparisons between medical students and junior doctors (two sub-populations with different responsibilities and time commitments) were conducted using Chi-square analyses for categorical values (e.g., sex, and entry to medical school), and Mann-Whitney U test for nonparametric continuous variables (e.g., age). Statistical significance was determined if type I error rate was < 5% (p-value < 0.05). All analyses were performed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences software (SPSS Statistics®, version 22.0.0.0).

III. RESULTS

A. Study Participants

A total of 93 eligible participants were identified as potential participants. Following electronic invitation, 47 returned the follow-up survey (response rate: 47/93 = 50.5%). Two thirds (31/47; 66%) of the respondents were female. The median age was 23 years (range, 19–42). Most of the respondents (40/47, 85.1%) were medical students (see Table 1).

Submitted: 13 February 2024
Accepted: 28 April 2025
Published online: 1 July, TAPS 2025, 10(3), 75-79
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/SC3235

Tayzar Hein¹ & Susan Somerville²

¹Department of Medical Education, Defence Services Medical Academy, Myanmar; ²University of Dundee, Scotland

Abstract

Introduction: Case-Based Learning (CBL) is increasingly used in modern medical schools to improve students’ critical thinking and problem-solving skills. While CBL is established in Western Resource-Structured (WRS) educational settings, its use in Asian-Pacific regions like Myanmar is under explored. This research studied the integration of CBL at the Defence Services Medical Academy (DSMA) in Myanmar, focusing on the perspectives of both students and faculty involved in curriculum reforms.

Methods: This study used constructivist grounded theory to gather data from 24 DSMA participants through four focus group discussions. Twelve students and twelve faculty members, were invited a subgroup of six, and after providing informed consent discussed their experiences of CBL, aiming to assess its effectiveness and relevance in their specific educational and cultural context.

Result: Analysis shows that students valued CBL for enhancing group discussions, reflecting upon real-world situations, and building critical thinking abilities. Faculty members also appreciated CBL for its capacity to create realistic applications and its support for student-centered learning and interpersonal skills development. Both groups acknowledged CBL as an effective method for simulating the complexities of medical practice.

Conclusion: This study found that CBL is well-regarded at DSMA for preparing students competence and confidence for clinical encounters. However, faculty indicated that the extensive time required in preparation of this teaching modality was a significant challenge for the wider adoption of CBL. These insights highlight the adaptability and potential challenges of implementing CBL in non-Western educational settings and suggest possible areas for development for its broader application in the Asia-Pacific region.

Keywords:           Medical Education, Case-based Learning, Perceptions, Grounded Theory, Focus Group Discussion

I. INTRODUCTION

In 2017, Defence Services Medical Academy (DSMA) in Yangon, Myanmar, introduced an outcome-based integrated curriculum incorporating Case-Based Learning (CBL) as a key pedagogical approach. This shift from teacher-centered to student-centered learning was aimed at encouraging students to take greater responsibility for their education. However, CBL’s widespread adoption across all subjects at DSMA remains uncertain, highlighting the need for further research. CBL has been established in Western Resource-Structured (WRS) medical education, where it fosters critical thinking, active learning, and problem-solving skills (Thistlethwaite et al., 2012). However, its adoption in the Asian-Pacific context, including Myanmar, has been limited. Cultural and institutional challenges such as insufficient faculty training, resource constraints, and resistance to pedagogical change present unique barriers (McLean, 2016; Yoo & Park, 2015). These challenges underline the importance of research to adapt CBL to resource-constrained settings.

At DSMA, CBL is relatively new, and while the institution can be considered an early adopter within the local context, faculty have faced challenges transitioning from traditional teaching methods due to inadequate training and support (Thistlethwaite et al., 2012). This study aimed to explore how students and faculty perceive the implementation of CBL and to assess the opportunities and challenges of CBL in a resource-constrained, Asian-Pacific context. By addressing gaps in the CBL literature, this research contributes valuable insights for adapting pedagogical practices to diverse cultural and educational settings.

This study aimed to explore:

1. How students and faculty at DSMA perceive the implementation of CBL.
2. The opportunities and challenges associated with implementing CBL in a resource-constrained, Asian-Pacific context.

 

By addressing gaps in the CBL literature, particularly in non-WRS settings, this research contributes to a better understanding of how pedagogical practices can be adapted to diverse cultural and educational contexts, offering insights for both early and late adopters within similar settings.

II. METHODS

This qualitative study used a constructivist grounded theory approach, focusing on the experiences and meanings constructed by participants engaged with CBL in the DSMA integrated curriculum.

A. Sampling and Focus Group Composition

Purposive sampling (Patton, 2014) was used to select participants with direct involvement in CBL activities, either as facilitators or active learners. The study included 24 participants, evenly split between 12 students and 12 faculty members. Four focus groups, each containing six participants, were conducted. To reduce power dynamics, the focus groups were divided by role, with separate groups for students and faculty.

B. Participant Demographics

Table 1 below shows the demographic breakdown of participants is for understanding the responses and receptivity to CBL.

Table 1. Participant demographic

C. Theoretical Framework

The constructivist grounded theory approach guided both data collection and analysis. This approach emphasises the co-construction of knowledge, meaning participants not only shared their experiences but actively engaged in interpreting them. The analysis followed a constant comparative method (Patton, 2014), allowing key themes to emerge from the data.

D. Data Analysis

Data were analysed using MAXQDA software, and the constant comparative method was applied to identify recurring themes and refine categories as new insights developed.

E. Ethical Considerations

Ethical approval was granted by the DSMA Ethical Review Board. Informed consent was obtained from all participants, ensuring they were aware of the study’s aims and their rights. Confidentiality and anonymity were maintained throughout the study, and all focus group discussions were audio-recorded with consent.

III. RESULTS

The core category identified in the study was that CBL is a student-centered approach that develops critical thinking, simulates discussion about real-world scenarios, and enhances interpersonal skills, making it a key facet of modern medical education. These findings emphasise the role of CBL in bridging theoretical knowledge with practical application and supporting the development of essential skills for clinical encounters. Both students and faculty members offered different but aligned perspectives, providing valuable insights into the opportunities and challenges associated with CBL.

A. Students’ Perceptions of CBL

1) Theme 1: CBL as group discussion: Students welcomed the collaborative nature of CBL, emphasising the shared learning experience it offers. One student stated, “It’s like a team effort where we learn from each other while solving problems.” This highlights the significance of peer interaction in CBL, which is consistent with research indicating that collaborative learning enhances problem-solving skills.

2) Theme 2: Real-World Relevance: Students appreciated the practical aspects of CBL, particularly its similarity to real-life clinical scenarios. A participant remarked, “It feels like we are preparing for actual hospital situations.” This theme aligns with studies showing how CBL effectively bridges the gap between theoretical knowledge and clinical practice, preparing students for real-world medical challenges.

3) Theme 3: Fostering Critical Thinking: Students frequently mentioned the role of CBL in promoting deeper analytical skills. One student shared, “CBL makes us analyse why things happen instead of just memorising.” This observation reflects the literature that highlights critical thinking as a fundamental outcome of CBL, encouraging students to engage more deeply with the material.

B. Faculty Perceptions of CBL

1) Theme 1: Preparation for Clinical Practice: Faculty members emphasised the effectiveness of CBL in preparing students for real-world medical contexts. One faculty member noted, “CBL allows students to apply their knowledge in realistic medical contexts.” This highlights the need for carefully designed scenarios that accurately mimic clinical challenges, supporting students in applying theoretical knowledge.

2) Theme 2: The Role of Facilitator: Faculty highlighted the critical role of facilitators in guiding effective CBL sessions. A faculty member stated, “Guiding discussions and asking the right questions is key to effective CBL sessions.” This underscores the importance of facilitator training, as their competence significantly impacts the success of CBL in achieving its objectives.

3) Theme 3: Development of Personal Skills: Faculty also emphasised the role of CBL in cultivating essential personal skills for medical practice, such as communication and empathy. One faculty member remarked, “CBL is instrumental in teaching students how to communicate effectively and empathise with patients, which are essential skills in medicine.” This theme reflects a structured focus on skill development, complementing students’ emphasis on the experiential aspects of learning.

IV. DISCUSSION

This study identified both the opportunities and challenges of adopting CBL in a resource-constrained, Asian-Pacific context. Students recognised CBL’s role in fostering teamwork and critical thinking, consistent with previous research (Ferguson & Lee, 2012; Thistlethwaite et al., 2012). Faculty highlighted its effectiveness in preparing students for clinical practice and developing essential interpersonal skills. However, both groups noted challenges, such as the time-intensive nature of CBL and the varying levels of facilitator preparedness.

A. Student Perspectives

Students appreciated the collaborative nature of CBL, noting that it enhanced communication and problem-solving skills. They also valued its practical relevance, which bridged the gap between theory and clinical practice. However, challenges related to the time commitment and inconsistent preparation for case studies were identified.

B. Faculty Perspectives

Faculty acknowledged the value of CBL in preparing students for real-world challenges but emphasised the importance of facilitator training. Inconsistent facilitation was cited as a barrier to effective implementation, suggesting the need for structured training programs focusing on communication and group management skills.

C. Adapting CBL for the Asian-Pacific Context

Cultural dynamics at DSMA, including hierarchical relationships, were seen as barriers to open dialogue and peer-led activities. Strategies such as peer-led activities and anonymous feedback could help mitigate these issues, creating a more inclusive and collaborative environment. Although hierarchical relationships are common across educational settings, these challenges may be viewed as institutional factors rather than unique cultural issues. Thus, the solutions proposed peer-led activities and feedback are relevant for various contexts beyond Asian-Pacific.

D. Core Category and Future Directions

The findings underscore the need for ongoing research to explore facilitation models and cultural adaptations that can optimise CBL in diverse settings. Future studies should examine how CBL can be further refined to address institutional factors like hierarchical relationships, and how these adaptations can be applied in resource-limited settings.

V. CONCLUSION

This study highlights both the strengths and challenges of implementing CBL at DSMA. Students valued CBL for its relevance to clinical scenarios and its emphasis on clinical reasoning, while faculty recognised its potential in fostering interpersonal skills. However, challenges such as inconsistent facilitation, insufficient faculty training, and the lack of localised case studies were identified. Moving forward, DSMA should focus on enhancing faculty development, particularly in facilitation skills, and integrate case studies that reflect local clinical realities. Additionally, leveraging technology to support CBL in resource-limited settings could improve access and engagement.

For the broader health education community, this study underscores the importance of adapting CBL to local contexts, considering cultural dynamics and institutional constraints. Successful implementation of CBL in resource-constrained settings requires flexibility in adapting global pedagogical methods to meet the needs of local learners and educators. Expanding CBL at DSMA, with a focus on faculty training, case study development, and the use of technology, will better prepare students for the challenges of medical practice. This study contributes to the growing body of literature on CBL and provides actionable recommendations for institutions in similar settings.

Notes on Contributors

Dr. Tayzar Hein contributed significantly to the manuscript’s conception, design, and writing, leveraging his expertise to shape its content.

Dr. Susan Somerville provided essential support during the research process, particularly in data collection and analysis, contributing to the manuscript’s presentation.

Ethical Approval

Ethics approval was granted by the Ethical Review Committee of the DSMA, Ethical Review Board (2/ ERB/ 2022).

Data Availability

The data that support the findings of this study are openly available in https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.26550262.v1.

Acknowledgement

The author would like to express sincere gratitude to their supervisor, Dr Susan Somerville, for her thoughtful guidance throughout the research project. Dr Susan Somerville provided invaluable suggestions, constant encouragement, and generously dedicated her time during video chats, despite being on the other side of the world. The support of the Ethical Review Committee at DSMA is also deeply appreciated. Their rigorous adherence to ethical standards ensured that the study met the highest research ethics guidelines, which is essential to both advancing medical knowledge and protecting human subjects.

Special thanks are extended to the Phase II medical students and faculty members who participated in interviews and provided honest, insightful discussions that significantly contributed to the research. Phase II students, typically in the years of medical education, engage in more clinical-based learning and were crucial in offering perspectives on applying Case-Based Learning (CBL) to real-world medical scenarios. Faculty members from both basic science and clinical practice domains also played an integral role in facilitating these discussions. The assistance of the Medical Education Department faculty in facilitating these interviews was also instrumental, and their support is gratefully acknowledged.

Finally, the author wishes to express heartfelt thanks to his wife and son for their unwavering support and encouragement throughout the academic journey. Without their constant love and understanding, this research project would not have been possible.

Funding

This research is entirely self-funded, as there is currently no external financial support available for the project, necessitating the coverage of all expenses independently.

Declaration of Interest

The author conducted original research and wrote this dissertation, which was not previously submitted for a degree. The author has the copyright to the dissertation according to UK Copyright Acts and University of Dundee’s rules. Any use of material from this thesis should be acknowledged.

References

Ferguson, A., & Lee, E. (2012). Desperately seeking… relevant assessment? A case study on the potential for using online simulated group based learning to create sustainable assessment practices. Legal Education Review, 22(1), Article 6. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.53300/​001c.6258

McLean, S. F. (2016). Case-based learning and its application in medical and health-care fields: A review of worldwide literature. Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development, 3, S20377. 

Patton, M. Q. (2014). Qualitative research & evaluation methods: Integrating theory and practice (4^th ed.). SAGE Publications.

Thistlethwaite, J. E., Davies, D., Ekeocha, S., Kidd, J. M., MacDougall, C., Matthews, P., Purkis, J., & Clay, D. J. (2012). The effectiveness of case-based learning in health professional education. A BEME systematic review: BEME Guide No. 23. Medical Teacher, 34(6), e421-e444. https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2012.680939

Yoo, M. S., & Park, H. R. (2015). Effects of case‐based learning on communication skills, problem‐solving ability, and learning motivation in nursing students. Nursing & Health Sciences, 17(2), 166-172. https://doi.org/10.1111/nhs.12151

*Tayzar Hein
Defence Services Medical Academy,
Pyay Road, Mingalardon Township,
Yangon, Myanmar
+9595188093
Email: dr.tayzarhein@gmail.com

https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/TT003

Gominda Ponnamperuma

MBBS, MMEd, PhD
Professor in Medical Education
Faculty of Medicine, University of Colombo, Sri Lanka

Standard setting is the process of deciding the boundary or standard that separates the candidates into two (e.g. pass and fail) or more groups, based on their ability shown at an assessment. Standard setting methods can be broadly grouped into four clusters (see table below).

When to use which method, though a crucial decision for any Board of Examiners, is inadequately explored in the literature. The following brief guide attempts to bridge this literature gap.

Cluster of methods	Key features	Issues	When to use
Arbitrary standards and norm-referenced standards	Arbitrary standards produce a fixed pass mark, e.g., candidates scoring 50% or more pass. Norm-referenced standards produce a fixed pass rate, e.g., 40% of top-scoring candidates pass.	The pass mark is unrelated to the difficulty of assessment items.	Arbitrary standards: not indicated for high-stakes assessment. Norm-referencing: used for selection purposes.
Test-centred methods	A group of experts (judges) estimate the probability of a hypothetical borderline (a candidate who has a 50% probability of passing or failing) or a just-passing candidate passing the test items, e.g. Angoff (1971), Ebel (1972), Nedelsky (1954), Bookmark (Karantonis & Sireci, 2006), Jaeger (1982). The judges’ estimates are collated through an averaging process. An expert (judge) is a subject-matter specialist, with considerable experience as a teacher and an assessor, well versed with the educational basis behind standard setting.	Although the pass mark is directly related to the difficulty of test items, human judgement is not infallible: The pass mark can vary from one panel of judges to another, even for the same test. finding a sizeable group of experts (at least 8) satisfying all requirements is difficult. it is difficult for judges to visualise a hypothetical borderline candidate. the process is time-consuming. Due to the above difficulties, the pass mark can be unrealistic.	When an adequate number of properly trained and experienced expert judges who can devote quality time to the standard setting process is available. When modifications such as the Modified Angoff method can be used to overcome unrealistic standards by allowing judges to be informed by actual results of previous similar exams.
Partially results-based methods-I: Examinee-centred methods	Based on actual candidate performance, judges group candidates into two or more groups, e.g. Borderline group (Smee & Blackmore, 2001), Borderline regression (Kramer et al., 2003), Contrasting groups (p.35) (Livingston & Zieky, 1982) and Up-down (p.43) (Livingston & Zieky, 1982) methods. The pass mark is calculated using the actual candidate scores.	Although judgements are realistic, the introduction of actual test results tends to make the standard cohort-dependent, i.e., norm-referencing features influence the standard.	When there is a sufficiently large number of candidates. When a global score or a global pass/fail decision is available, in addition to the usual itemized score. When the judges are well-trained in making a global decision independent of the itemised scores.
Partially results-based methods-II: Compromise methods	Judges make judgements by looking at test items, and those judgements are superimposed on actual candidate scores to derive the pass mark, e.g., Hofstee method (Hofstee, 1973).	Expert judgements and actual results may not match each other. The standard can be cohort-dependent due to the norm-referencing features of actual candidate scores.	When trained judges, actual results of a sizable cohort of candidates and expertise in handling both judges’ judgements and results are available. Mostly used as a backup method to verify standards generated by other methods.
Results-based methods	Judges are not needed for standard setting. The pass mark is generated by statistically manipulating the actual marks, e.g. Cohen (Cohen- Schotanus & van der Vleuten, 2010) and Wijnen (1971) methods.	Due to the norm-referencing influence, the pass mark could be high and defensibility would be an issue.	These methods should be used in high-stakes assessment only when an adequate evidence base is built by conducting them parallelly with another more established method.

 

References

Angoff, W. H. (1971). Scales, norms, and equivalent scores. In R. L. Thorndike (Ed.), Educational measurement (2^nd ed., pp. 508-600). American Council on Education.

Ebel, R. L. (1972). Essentials of educational measurement. Prentice Hall.

Nedelsky, L. (1954). Absolute grading standards for objective tests. Educational and Psychological Measurement, 14(1), 3-19. https://doi.org/10.1177/001316445401400101

Karantonis, A., & Sireci, S. G. (2006). The bookmark standard-setting method: A literature review. Educational Measurement Issues and Practice, 25(1), 4-12. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-3992.2006.00047.x

Jaeger, R. M. (1982). An iterative structured judgment process for establishing standards on competency test: Theory and application. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 4(4), 461-476. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737004004461

Smee, S. M., & Blackmore, D. E. (2001). Setting standards for an Objective Structured Clinical Examination: The borderline group method gains ground on Angoff. Medical Education, 35(11), 1009-1010. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.2001.01047.x

Kramer, A., Muijtjens, A., Jansen, K., Dusman, H., Tan, L., & van der Vleuten, C. (2003) Comparison of a rational and an empirical standard setting procedure for an OSCE. Medical Education, 37(2), 132-139. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01429.x

Livingston, S. A., & Zieky, M. J. (1982). Passing scores: A manual for setting standards of performance on educational and occupational tests. Educational Testing Service.

Hofstee, W. K. B. (1973). Een alternatief voor normhandhaving bij toetsen. Nederlands Tijdschrift voor de Psychologie, 28, 215-227.

Cohen-Schotanus, J., & van der Vleuten, C. P. M. (2010). A standard setting method with the best performing students as point of reference: Practical and affordable. Medical Teacher, 32(2), 154-160. https://doi.org/10.3109/01421590903196979

Wijnen, W. H. F. W. (1971). Onder of boven de maat. Amsterdam: Swets & Zeitlinger.

Submitted: 30 October 2024
Accepted: 8 April 2025
Published online: 1 July, TAPS 2025, 10(3), 89-92
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/SC3562

Shanya Shanmugam¹, Rajeswari Kathirvel^1,2, Kayda Soh² & Xinyi Li^1,2

¹Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, Singapore; ²Division of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital, Singapore

Abstract

Introduction: The Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) is a popular method for assessing medical students’ clinical proficiency. Mock OSCEs are often incorporated into medical curricula to help students familiarise themselves with the examination format. While the impact of mock OSCEs on academic performance has been studied, their perceived utility remains less explored. This study aimed to assess the effectiveness of a mock OSCE in preparing medical students for their final examinations.

Methods: A prospective study was conducted at a tertiary hospital in Singapore, involving medical students undergoing their Obstetrics and Gynaecology posting. The mock OSCE consisted of five stations and included immediate feedback from examiners. Students completed three questionnaires: pre-mock OSCE, post-mock OSCE and post final examinations, rating the utility of the session and their confidence levels.

Results:  Of the cohort of 147 students, 121 responded to the pre-mock OSCE survey, 132 responded to the post-mock OSCE survey, and 105 to the survey after their final examinations. The percentage of students who found the mock OSCE useful/very useful increased significantly from 97.5% before to 98.5% after the session, and significantly decreased to 96.2% after the examinations. Confidence levels rose significantly from a mean score of 2.34/5 pre-mock to 3.89/5 post-mock, to 4.67/5 post-exam. Qualitative feedback was positive, highlighting the benefit of familiarisation with examination mark schemes.

Conclusion: The mock OSCE was well-received by students and perceived as a valuable tool in preparation for examinations. Despite the limited sample size, these findings support the implementation of mock OSCEs to enhance students’ learning and exam preparedness.

Keywords:           OSCE, Undergraduate, Medical Education, Medicine, Students’ Perception

I. INTRODUCTION

The Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) is a well-established, widely utilised method for assessing the clinical proficiency of medical students. This format comprises multiple stations where students perform clinical tasks, including history taking, physical examination, and discussing clinical management. Despite being a crucial assessment tool, OSCEs can be a daunting experience for medical students. Educational institutions often incorporate mock OSCEs into curricula to alleviate this stress, allowing students to familiarise themselves with the format and receive feedback. These sessions aim to mimic the actual OSCE, allowing students to familiarise themselves with the format and requirements, and offer an opportunity to receive feedback. 

The correlation between mock OSCE practice and performance in the actual OSCE has yielded mixed results in literature. Studies on medical students (Townsend et al., 2001), and residents from internal medicine (Pugh et al., 2016), paediatrics (Hilliard et al., 1998), and emergency medicine (Lee et al., 2021) have established positive correlations between mock OSCE scores and final examination scores. Conversely, a study on second-year medical students concluded that while the mock OSCE led to improved performance in individual stations, it did not cause a significant change in the pass rate of the final examinations (Chisnall et al., 2015).

While the impact of mock OSCEs on students’ academic performance has been examined, the perception of their utility among participants has not been extensively analysed. As OSCE is viewed as a stressful component of medical assessments, the introduction of mock OSCE sessions is thought to mitigate this stress by fostering confidence and familiarity among students (Chisnall et al., 2015).

We performed a study to determine the perceived effectiveness of a mock OSCE in preparing its participants for their final examinations. More specifically, the study aimed to assess whether participation in the mock OSCEs improved students’ understanding of the domain-based exam scoring system employed by markers, enhanced their time management skills, delivered valuable content, helped them develop effective approaches to OSCE stations, and boosted their confidence levels.

II. METHODS

This prospective study evaluated students’ perceptions of the mock OSCE’s utility. This was conducted at KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital (KKH), which is a tertiary hospital in Singapore. KKH caters to students from the three different medical schools in Singapore including Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine (LKC), Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine and Duke-NUS Medical school.

A mock OSCE programme was organised by the Obstetrics and Gynaecology (O&G) department for the fourth-year medical students from LKC during their O&G posting from 2022-2023. The mock OSCE was conducted three times as the students attended in three streams. This is the first of such a programme in the O&G curriculum and was introduced as this cohort had reduced clinical exposure due to COVID-19 restrictions during their clinical years.

The mock OSCE included five 10-minute stations covering history taking, physical examination, and clinical management in O&G. Students were evaluated according to the domain-based scoring system used by LKC for their final examinations. The assessment was designed to be formative in nature and the students received immediate feedback at the conclusion of each station. 

The students were asked to complete anonymous questionnaires before and after participating in the mock OSCE, and after completing their final year examinations. A 4-point Likert scale was used to gauge the usefulness of the mock OSCE session, with 1 being “not useful at all” and 4 being “very useful” and a 5-point Likert scale was used to gauge confidence for final examinations, where 1 represented “not confident” and 5 represented “very confident”. The responses collected before and after the mock OSCE session were compared. The study also examined the impact of the mock OSCE on insight into exam scoring system, time management, and content relevance through Likert scale questions. Qualitative feedback was obtained through open-text responses. The data obtained through the Likert scales were combined into nominal categories. Statistical significance was determined by performing Chi-square tests, with p<0.05 being considered significant.  Informed consent was implied through the voluntary participation of individuals in the questionnaires.

The study was approved and given exempt status by the Nanyang Technological University Institutional Review Board for research (IRB 2023-677).

III. RESULTS

There were 147 fourth-year medical students for the academic year 2022–2023. 121 students responded to the questionnaire prior to the mock OSCE (82.3%), 122 (83.0%) after the mock OSCE, and 105 (71.4%) after their final examinations.

Before the mock OSCE, 97 (80.8%) students believed that it would be very useful for their exam preparation, while 20 (16.7%) believed it would be useful, and 3 (2.5%) were unsure. After the mock OSCE, 120 (91.6%) students thought it was very useful for their exam preparation, with 9 (6.9%) believing it was useful, 1 (0.8%) being unsure, and 1 (0.8%) believing it was not useful. After the final examinations, 77 (74.8%) students found it to be very useful for their exam preparation, 22 (21.4%) found it was useful, 3 (2.9%) were unsure, and 1 (1.0%) found it was not useful (Figure 1). Overall, the percentage of students who found the mock OSCE useful/very useful increased from 97.5% before to 98.5% after the session and decreased to 96.2% after the examinations. The difference in perceived utility of the mock OSCE, as determined by the combining “very useful” and “useful” into one category and “unsure” and “not useful” into another, from before the OSCE, after the OSCE, and after the examinations, was statistically significant at p<0.05, with a p-value of 0.0147.

Figure 1. Comparison of perceived utility of mock OSCE

When asked to rate their confidence regarding their final examinations, the overall score improved from 2.34/5 before the mock OSCE to 3.89/5 after, to 4.67/5 after the examinations. This rise in confidence levels was statistically significant, with a p-value of <0.00001. 

We asked the students to rate the domain that they found the mock OSCE helped them with the most, including improved insight into domain-based exam scoring system, improved time management, useful content, prepare an approach for OSCE stations, and improved confidence. Almost a third (n = 32, 30.5%) of the students found that the mock OSCE helped them to prepare an approach for OSCE stations the most. This was followed by improved confidence (28, 26.7%), improved insight into exam scoring system (21, 20.0%), useful content (15, 14.3%), and lastly, time management (9, 8.6%). Furthermore, a majority of students (n=70, 66.7%) felt that the O&G mock OSCE was helpful not only for the O&G component, but for the entire OSCE examination.

Qualitative feedback obtained from the students was largely positive. The common theme that surfaced was how the mock OSCE allowed students to familiarise themselves with what to expect from the final examination. Examples include:

“Helped to give us a broader understanding of how 1) clinician thinks and how 2) an examiner grades.”

“It was a great opportunity for medical students to learn about history taking and physical examination in a controlled environment.”

IV. DISCUSSION

Overall, the mock OSCE was well-received by students as a useful tool in preparation for final examinations. The differences in the perceived utility of the mock OSCE from before the OSCE, after the OSCE, and after their final examinations was statistically significant. This supports the value of the mock OSCE programme, given the students’ lack of exposure to clinical scenarios and examination structure as previously outlined. Interestingly, the proportion of students who found the mock OSCE programme useful/very useful decreased from 98.5% after the OSCE to 96.2% after final examinations. This drop can be explained by the qualitative feedback obtained, which cites the examination’s increased complexity and variations in content.

Most students felt that the mock OSCE helped them prepare their approach to OSCE stations, consistent with previous studies showing that mock OSCEs help students familiarise themselves with the format. (Lee et al., 2021, Chisnall et al., 2015) These sentiments are echoed in the qualitative feedback obtained. Furthermore, the difference in confidence levels before and after the mock OSCE was statistically significant.

This study is limited by its small sample size, ranging from 105 to 132 students. As participation was voluntary and the questions were not compulsory, some students did not complete the survey, leading to discrepancies in response rates. Furthermore, due to the anonymous nature of the surveys, we are unable to monitor for survey drop-offs. Using Likert scales to assess the utility of the mock OSCE may not fully capture participants’ opinions. Students may have interpreted the scales differently, as utility is subjective to the individuals’ standards for themselves. This could have resulted in less reliable data due to the diversity in how participants understood the scales.

V. CONCLUSION

The results of this study indicate that a mock OSCE is perceived to be an important part of examination preparation for medical students. Despite being a single-specialty mock OSCE, most students felt it was useful for preparing for their entire final exam.

These findings suggest that there is great potential in using mock OSCEs as a revision tool for medical students and support the implementation of such programmes to guide students in their learning and examination preparation.

Notes on Contributors

Shanya Shanmugam is a medical student at Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine, who is interested in medical education. She reviewed the literature, analysed data and wrote the manuscript.

Dr Rajeswari Kathirvel is a senior consultant at KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital and the principal lead for Obstetrics and Gynaecology at Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine. She, alongside with Dr Li Xinyi, designed the study, developed the questionnaire, and developed the manuscript.

Kayda Soh is an executive in KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital OBGYN Academic Clinical Programme. She was involved in administering the questionnaires and collating the data.

Dr Li Xinyi is a consultant at KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital and the posting lead for Obstetrics and Gynaecology at Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine. She, alongside with Dr Rajeswari Kathirvel, designed the study, developed the questionnaire, and developed the manuscript.

Ethical Approval

The study was approved and given exempt status by the Nanyang Technological University Institutional Review Board for research (IRB 2023-677).

Data Availability

The data that support the findings of this study are openly available in the Figshare repository, at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.25903786.

Acknowledgement

We would like to thank the students at Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine who participated in this study.

Funding

The authors report that there is no funding associated with the work featured in this article.

Declaration of Interest

The authors report there are no competing interests to declare.

References

Chisnall, B., Vince, T., Hall, S., & Tribe, R. (2015). Evaluation of outcomes of a formative objective structured clinical examination for second-year UK medical students. International Journal of Medical Education, 6, 76–83. https://doi.org/10.5116/ijme.5572.a534

Hilliard, R. I., & Tallett, S. E. (1998). The use of an objective structured clinical examination with postgraduate residents in Pediatrics. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 152(1). https://doi.org/10.1001/archpedi.152.1.74

Lee, M. H., Phua, D. H., & Heng, K. W. (2021). The use of a formative OSCE to prepare emergency medicine residents for summative OSCE: A mixed-methods cohort study. Research Square. https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-495003/v1

Pugh, D., Bhanji, F., Cole, G., Dupre, J., Hatala, R., Humphrey-Murto, S., Touchie, C., & Wood, T. J. (2016). Do OSCE progress test scores predict performance in a national high-stakes examination? Medical Education, 50(3), 351–358. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12942

Townsend, A. H., Mcllvenny, S., Miller, C. J., & Dunn, E. V. (2001). The use of an objective structured clinical examination (OSCE) for formative and summative assessment in a general practice clinical attachment and its relationship to final medical school examination performance. Medical Education, 35(9), 841–846. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2923.2001.00957.x

*Shanya Shanmugam
Lee Kong Chian School of Medicine,
11 Mandalay Road,
Singapore
Email: shanya001@e.ntu.edu.sg

Submitted: 19 October 2024
Accepted: 28 April 2025
Published online: 1 July, TAPS 2025, 10(3), 84-88
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/SC3547

Eranthi Weeratunga, Shashika Karunanayaka, Pramudika Kariyawasam & Bimba Wickramarachchi

Department of Nursing, Faculty of Allied Health Sciences, University of Ruhuna, Sri Lanka

Abstract

Introduction: Palliative care nursing (PCN) supports individuals with life-threatening illnesses, aiming to improve the quality of life (QoL) for patients and families. The objective was to assess the necessity of establishing an Advanced Certificate Course in PCN at University of Ruhuna, Sri Lanka.

Methods: A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted among 220 registered nurses (RNs) using purposive sampling, working at National Hospital Galle. A pre-tested, interviewer-administered questionnaire was used, including questions on prior education or training experiences on palliative care (PC), and its principles, services, and management. Descriptive statistics and the chi-square test were used to analyse.

Results: The majority of the RNs were aged 31-40 years (45.2%), females (86.0%), and married (55.7%). A higher proportion of RNs were nursing diploma holders (67.4%), with 55.7% having less than ten years of nursing experience. Only 11.3% of the RNs had formal additional training on PC, such as workshops and a few training hours. Most RNs correctly identified PC aims: improving survival (59.7%), improving QoL of patients and their families (91.4%), providing relief and pain (93.7%), understanding PC (80.1%), etc. The majority (84.6%) had a good attitude toward palliative caregiving, though only 20.4% had average knowledge of PC. Formal PCN training was significantly associated with PC knowledge (p=0.004).

Conclusion: Limited educational exposure, average knowledge levels, and good attitudes toward PC suggest the need for a PCN course for nurses. Providing a special education programme reduces the current gaps in PC by equipping RNs with the respective knowledge, skills, and attitudes to deliver complex management for patients requiring PC.

Keywords:           Palliative Care Nursing, Sri Lanka, Educational Needs, Registered Nurse

I. INTRODUCTION

Palliative care (PC) is an approach that aims to improve the quality of life (QoL) of patients and their families facing the physical, psychosocial, and spiritual problems associated with life-threatening illnesses (World Health Organization [WHO], 2022). About forty million people need a PC every year in the world, but the majority are from lower-middle-income countries (LMICs) (WHO, 2022). PC is offered by a range of professionals comprising physicians, nurses, support workers, etc., who are equally important, in addition to family members (WHO, 2022).

The major obstacle to improving PC among healthcare professionals (HCPs) and policymakers in LMICs is a lack of education/training (WHO, 2022) and a need for knowledge on PC for nursing professionals, which emphasised in previous findings in Sri Lanka (Meegoda et al., 2018) in addition to less PC content in the undergraduate curriculum (Pesut & Greig, 2018).  Further, less awareness of PC, cultural/social barriers, and misconceptions was found among HCPs; PC education improved nurses’ knowledge, confidence, attitudes, and communication abilities (WHO, 2022).  In Sri Lanka, there is a growing number of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), such as cancers, end-stage renal disease, HIV/AIDS, motor neuron disease, etc., that require comprehensive PC at every stage of the disease process in addition to the rapidly aging population.

PC services in Sri Lanka remain limited due to a shortage of trained HCPs. In response to the rising burden of NCDs, the Ministry of Health has emphasised the need to strengthen PC across all levels of the healthcare system. However, gaps in knowledge, skills, and attitudes among HCPs hinder effective implementation. While universities have introduced theoretical PC education, nursing undergraduates receive minimal practical exposure. Although a one-year post-basic diploma in palliative care nursing (PCN) has been launched for registered nurses (RNs), it is insufficient to meet the growing national demand. The initiation of a new course is of paramount importance, as specialisation in PCN has become an urgent necessity both nationally and internationally. The rising number of patients requiring PC, driven by demographic transitions, underscores this need. In developed countries such as Japan and Australia, the demand for PCN is expected to increase due to aging populations. Nationwide studies in Japan estimated that PC needs will continue to rise. Evidence suggests a growing demand for PC services in Australia, in particular, as the number of Australians aged over 85 continues to increase, the need for PC services has also surged. As a result, the demand for Sri Lankan RNs specialising in PC is expected to rise in these developed countries.

To address the existing gaps in PC knowledge and skills among RNs, we sought to quantify RN’s readiness for specialisation in PCN. The key objective was to assess the necessity of establishing an Advanced Certificate Course in PCN at the Department of Nursing, Faculty of Allied Health Sciences (FAHS), University of Ruhuna (UoR), Sri Lanka, to enhance professional competency and meet the growing demand for PC services.

II. METHODS

This descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted at the National Hospital Galle (NGH), Sri Lanka. The study participants were 220 RNs purposively selected based on having at least one year of experience, surveyed from June to December 2023. Data were collected using a content-validated and pre-tested questionnaire, which had been previously utilised in a Sri Lankan study (Fernando & Prathapan, 2019). The questionnaire comprised sections designed to assess socio-demographic characteristics and knowledge of four distinct domains: basic principles, service organisation, clinical management, and ethical considerations. Additionally, participants’ attitudes were evaluated after obtaining written informed consent. Statistical Package for Social Science (SPSS) 26 software was used; the descriptive statistics, frequencies, and percentages were checked. Further, a chi-square test was used. All results were regarded as statistically significant at p < 0.05.

III. RESULTS

The majority of the RNs were aged 31-40 years (45.2%). The mean±SD age was 36.61 ± 7.47 years. The majority were female (86.0%) and married (55.7%). Of the RNs, 35.7% had a monthly income between Sri Lankan Rupees 50,000 and 74,999. A higher proportion of RNs were nursing diploma holders (67.4%), with 55.7% having less than ten years of nursing experience. Emergency trauma care was the special training received by the RNs (4.5%). Only 11.3% of the RNs had formal additional training on PCN, such as workshops and a few training hours. Most RNs correctly identified PC aims (Table. 1). However, the majority gave incorrect answers regarding general knowledge/concepts of PC principles, such as increasing the life expectancy of terminally ill patients (59.7%) and consultants as ideal coordinators for PC (87.8%). Most RNs agreed that PC offers hope to patients (47.1%) and considered it a basic human right (79.6%). The majority (84.6%) had a good attitude toward PC, though only 20.4% had average knowledge of PC. Knowledge of PC was significantly associated with formal PCN training (p=0.004).

Table 1. General principles of PC among RNs, service organisation, drug management aspects, and ethical concerns

IV. DISCUSSION

This study assessed PC knowledge, management, ethical concerns, and attitudes among RNs in the NHG, Sri Lanka. RNs reported average knowledge and satisfactory attitudes, with age and prior PC training significantly influencing knowledge levels. Compared to the current study, Fernando and Prathapan (2019) reported higher satisfactory scores.

Sri Lankan medical graduates showed limited PC knowledge (37.23%), lower than RNs (20.4%), likely due to curriculum gaps (Fernando & Prathapan, 2019; Prem et al., 2012). While young medical graduates had adequate knowledge of general principles (63%), ethics was the weakest area (19.55%), mirroring findings among RNs.

PC is a relatively new discipline in Sri Lanka, contributing to limited ethical awareness. Cultural norms favor “hiding bitter truths” over transparency rather than “telling the truth,” which is a fundamental principle in Western healthcare practices, influencing attitudes and ethical concerns (Fernando & Prathapan, 2019).

The medical graduates studied by Fernando and Prathapan (2019) were younger than the RNs in this study. Despite some PC exposure, RNs had fewer opportunities for specialised training, impacting knowledge levels. Nevertheless, their positive attitudes likely stem from empathy-based patient care within the Asian context.

A previous study highlighted insufficient PC preparedness among nurses, attributing it to curriculum deficiencies and inadequate training in pain management (Prem et al., 2012). Female RNs performed better than males, but knowledge gaps remain a global issue. Student nurses and new RNs often feel inadequately prepared to discuss end-of-life issues, death, and other ethical concerns.

Meegoda et al. (2018) emphasised the need for adequate PC knowledge among nurses, as limited PC services worsen cancer care challenges. Heavy workloads and time constraints hinder learning, and 96% of RNs had not attended PC training. In-service programmes were considered beneficial, but specialised training is mainly available in Colombo, restricting accessibility. Distance learning could bridge this gap.

Nurses are vital in PC across various healthcare settings. Skilled PCNs provide essential support to patients and families. WHO (2022) stresses PC’s role in alleviating suffering and advocates its integration into national healthcare. However, LMICs face educational and awareness barriers.

Although Sri Lankan nurses have access to higher education, PC specialisation remains limited, especially in remote areas. With rising NCDs and aging populations, introducing PCN courses is crucial. Establishing a PCN programme aligned with national priorities would enhance patient care and improve career opportunities, particularly for nurses seeking employment abroad. A PCN course at FAHS, UoR, outside Colombo, could improve access to PC education.

A. Limitations

This study highlights the need for PC training, but it has limitations. Sampling bias may affect validity, and self-reported data could introduce response bias.

V. CONCLUSION

Limited educational exposure, average knowledge, and positive attitudes toward PC indicate a need for PCN courses to address existing gaps. RNs at NHG support an Advanced Certificate Course in PCN, emphasising the necessity for specialised training. Expanding PC education will enhance patient care and create new professional opportunities. Future research should assess the impact of PC training on HCP competencies and patient outcomes. Collaboration between the University of Ruhuna and the Ministry of Health is essential for establishing a sustainable PCN course.

Notes on Contributors

EW was involved in conceptual development, data collection/entry/analysis, manuscript drafting, editing, and final correction. SK was incorporated into conceptual development, data collection/entry/analysis, and editing. Data entry/analysis, editing, and final correction were done by PK, and BW was involved in manuscript draft editing.

Ethical Approval

Ethical approval (Ref. No. 83.11.2021) and institutional approval were obtained from the Ethics Review Committee of the FAHS, UoR, and the relevant institutions/authorities.  

Data Availability

Data analysed during the current study will be available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.

Acknowledgment

The authors are grateful to the Dean, FAHS, UoR, Galle, Sri Lanka, and the Head, Department of Nursing, FAHS, UoR, Galle, Sri Lanka. The Director, Chief Grade Nursing Officer, and all in-charge nursing sisters of the National Hospital Galle are acknowledged for their permission. Ms. Nimesha and Mr. Dilan (11th batch/nursing graduates) are appreciated for their enormous contribution while collecting data despite their busy schedules. All consented RNs were further acknowledged for giving their true opinions and great support to uplift nursing education in the PCN field. 

Funding

The authors received no funding for this study.

Declaration of Interest

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

References

Fernando, G. V. M. C., & Prathapan, S. (2019). What do young doctors know of palliative care; How do they expect the concept to work? BMC Research Notes, 12(1), 1–6. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13104-019-4462-2

Meegoda, D. L., Fernando, D. M. S., Atulomah, N., Sivayogan, S., & Marasinghe, R. B. (2018). Improvement of nurses’ skills following a hybrid model educational intervention on cancer palliative care. International Journal of Health Sciences & Research, 8(5), 196–203. http://www.ijhsr.org/IJHSR_Vol.8_Issue.5_May2018/IJHSR_Abstract.031.html

Pesut, B., & Greig, M. (2018). Resources for educating, training, and mentoring nurses and unregulated nursing care providers in palliative care: A review and expert consultation. Journal of Palliative Medicine, 21(S1), S50–S56. https://doi.org/10.1089/jpm.2017.0395

Prem, V., Karvannan, H., Kumar, S. P., Karthikbabu, S., Syed, N., Sisodia, V., & Jaykumar, S. (2012). Study of nurses’ knowledge about palliative care: A quantitative cross-sectional survey. Indian Journal of Palliative Care, 18(2), 122–127. https://doi.org/10.4103/0973-1075.100832

World Health Organization. (2022). Palliative care. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/palliative-care

*Eranthi Weeratunga
Department of Nursing,
Faculty of Allied Health Sciences,
University of Ruhuna
Galle, 80 000, Sri Lanka
+94 71 440 2662, +94 77 225 8519
Email: eranthiw@ahs.ruh.ac.lk,
eranthiweeratunga@yahoo.com

Submitted: 22 July 2024
Accepted: 4 February 2025
Published online: 1 July, TAPS 2025, 10(3), 80-83
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/SC3470

Zaitunnatakhin Zamli¹, Rohaini Ramli², Hidayah Sulaiman², Mohd Zulfaezal Che Azemin³, Wan Muhamad Salahudin Wan Salleh⁴, Nurul Asyiqin Yusof⁵, Imran Mahalil² & Azmi Mohd. Yusof²

¹Department of Biomedical Science, Kulliyyah of Allied Health Sciences, International Islamic University Malaysia, Malaysia; ²Department of Informatics, College of Computing & Informatics, Universiti Tenaga Nasional, Malaysia; ³Department of Optometry and Visual Sciences, Kulliyyah of Allied Health Sciences, International Islamic University Malaysia, Malaysia; ⁴Department of Basic Medical Sciences, Kulliyyah of Medicine, International Islamic University Malaysia, Malaysia; ⁵Department of Basic Medical Sciences, Kulliyyah of Pharmacy, International Islamic University Malaysia, Malaysia

Abstract

Introduction: Virtual reality (VR) has been widely used in medical and health sciences education since the late twentieth century. VR complements the conventional teaching and learning (T&L) approach by providing an engaging and immersive 3D spatial learning environment, especially for understanding the orientation of anatomical structures. Despite these advantages, the usability and student preference of highly immersive head-mounted display-based (HMD) and less immersive desktop-based (DB) VR in human anatomy courses have yet to be determined.

Methods: In a cross-sectional study, 49 Year-2 medical students were recruited through a convenient sampling. The participants were asked to identify 15 skeletal system components using the HMD and DB platform with human anatomy VR application. Both applications’ System Usability Scale (SUS) and preference scores were obtained via a self-administered questionnaire. The data were expressed as median [IQR] and statistically analysed using MATLAB R2022b.

Results: Most participants preferred the HMD over the DB platform (p=0.04), especially the male participants (p=0.01). There was no significant difference in overall SUS scores between both platforms (p=0.14). However, when compared within and between genders, females scored significantly higher in the DB than HMD (p=0.02) and higher than males’ DB SUS scores (p=0.03).

Conclusion: The overall usability of HMD was comparable with the DB platform for learning human anatomy. Although most participants prefer to use the HMD, further exploration of why females prefer the DB is needed. Subsequently, VR application developers must consider gender-related adaptions to promote the equitability and inclusivity of the technology for all users.

Keywords:           Human Anatomy, Virtual Reality, Head-mounted Display, Desktop-based Application, Usability, Preference

I. INTRODUCTION

Virtual reality (VR) is a simulated three-dimensional (3D) environment that enables users to explore and interact with virtual surroundings, perceiving them through their senses as if they were in the real world. It has been widely used in various fields, including education, to provide users with immersive, engaging, and experiential learning experiences.

In medical education, VR allows students to manipulate anatomical structures into different planes, sections and orientations in a simulated environment, benefiting learners with low-spatial ability. VR also helps students better grasp the relative size differences of organs and allows students to relate the location and position of the organs with their surroundings, resulting in better memorisation and learning outcomes, with VR groups outperforming control groups in post-test assessments (Kurul et al., 2020). As the current generation is more digitally savvy, most students are easily adapted to VR simulation, which enables them to grasp knowledge from a new perspective. For instance, students can dissect a muscle from the human body, gaining insight into the interaction and innervation of individual muscles during exercise.

However, despite the high acceptability of use in anatomy courses among students, some participants reported simulator sickness symptoms like headaches, dizziness, and blurred vision. These symptoms are more pronounced in females, who tend to experience discomfort in a VR environment (Stanney et al., 2020), potentially due to differences in spatial awareness, sensitivity to sensory stimuli, or physiological responses. In addition, regardless of gender, the mismatch between visual motion and the body’s sensory feedback in VR environments can lead to sensory conflict and an increased likelihood of discomfort.

While VR modalities show great potential in anatomy education, research comparing highly immersive head-mounted display-based (HMD) with less immersive desktop-based (DB) VR platforms, particularly regarding gender differences in usability and preferences, remains limited. In addition, considering the high cost of VR applications for HMD, addressing this knowledge gap before its development is crucial to ensuring optimal and cost-effective learning outcomes for a diverse student population. Therefore, this study aimed to compare the usability and preferences between DB and HMD platforms in exploring the VR anatomy applications, within and between genders, among medical students.

II. METHODS

Upon their written consent, forty-nine undergraduate medical students (23 males and 26 females, aged 19-21 years) were recruited through a convenience sampling. They were second-year medical students and participated in this study in two sessions. The participants were asked to identify 15 skeletal components (i.e. skull, vertebrae, hyoid bone, sternum, ribs, scapula, clavicle, humerus, radius, ulna, hip bone, femur, patella, tibia, and fibula) using two platforms: a head-mounted display-based (HMD) virtual reality system with the human anatomy VR application (BodyMap v3.2, https://www.mai.ai/bodymap), and a desktop-based (DB) application (Zygote Body, https://www.zygotebody.com/). BodyMap v3.2 is a VR application for exploring the human body in 3D using the Oculus Quest 2 headset, which provides an immersive and interactive experience for anatomy education. Meanwhile, Zygote Body is a web-based platform that offers detailed 3D anatomical models for desktop or laptop exploration.

Each platform was given a time limit of 15 minutes for the participants to complete the task. After completing the task, the participants completed the System Usability Scale (SUS), a 10-item questionnaire designed to measure the perceived usability of both platforms. The SUS score ranges from 0 (very poor usability) to 100 (perfect usability). In addition, the participants were also asked to rate their preference for using each platform on a scale from 1 (do not prefer at all) to 10 (most preferred). The data were expressed as median (interquartile range, IQR), which best represents the central tendency for non-normally distributed data. Normality was assessed using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, and the Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used to compare the median scores of SUS / Preferences within and between genders. All statistical analyses were performed using MATLAB R2022b, with a p-value < 0.05 considered statistically significant.

III. RESULTS

A. Demographic Data

Forty-nine Year-2 IIUM medical students participated in this study. Most of the students were female (n=26, 53%), with a mean age of 20.10 ± 0.37 years old. 

B. Comparison of SUS and Preference Scores between the HMD and DB

There was no significant difference between the median SUS scores between the HMD and DB applications (p=0.14). However, most students preferred the HMD (90, IQR 80.0-100.0) rather than the DB (80, IQR 75.0-90.0) applications (p=0.04).

C. Comparison of SUS and Preference Scores of the HMD and DB within and between Gender

The SUS and preference scores of the HMD and DB applications within and between genders are shown in Figure 1, and individual scores are accessible at https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.26711965. Based on gender, significantly higher median SUS scores were observed for the DB (85, IQR 77.5-95.0) than the HMD application (75, IQR 59.4-85.6) among the female students (p=0.02). In contrast, the male students had a significantly higher preference score for the HMD (100, IQR 85.0-100.0) than the DB application (80, IQR 70.0-90.0) (p=0.01). A significant difference between gender was only observed in the SUS score, in which the female students scored 85 (IQR, 77.5 – 95.0), and the male students scored 75 (IQR, 58.1 – 86.9; p=0.03) for the DB application.

 

Figure 1. Comparison of SUS and Preference median scores of the HMD and DB application within (A-B) and between genders (C-D). A significant difference of p≤0.05 is denoted as *.

IV. DISCUSSION

This study found that the overall usability scores of the head-mounted display-based (HMD) and the desktop-based (DB) in human anatomy VR applications are comparable. However, a significant gender-related difference was observed in the reported usability scores of the HMD. Female participants reported significantly better usability with the DB than the HMD, likely due to their unfamiliarity with the HMD modality and disadvantage in the 3D spatial ability than males in visualising and manipulating objects in the navigating space. While traditional explanations link these gender differences to brain lateralisation, Bartlett and Camba (2023) challenge this view, suggesting societal expectations and gender roles may shape spatial skills.

Despite this, the study also found that most participants, especially males, prefer the HMD over the DB. This preference might be due to males’ active engagement and early adaptation to the technology, particularly in online gaming, making it more intuitive. This aligns with Deisinger et al. (1997), who found that inexperienced users favoured screen-based projection due to their familiarity with the conventional technology over the HMD. Interestingly, although females perceived DB as more usable, this did not significantly affect their preference for HMD. Many females acknowledged needing more technical help with the HMD but believed they would quickly adapt and prefer it over time. The study’s findings resonate with prior research in medical education, where HMDs are favoured for their immersive experience, enhancing spatial or physical presence and interaction as compared to DB (Yamazaki et al., 2021). However, the effectiveness of HMDs in improving learning outcomes compared to traditional methods remains inconclusive.

Given HMDs’ potential to enhance anatomy education, further research is crucial, especially in complex topics like embryology and neuroanatomy. Developers must focus on high content quality, intuitive user interfaces, and user comfort to ensure a positive learning experience. Gender-related adaptations can promote inclusivity, ensuring that the educational benefits of HMDs are accessible to all users.

Three main limitations of the present study also warrant mention. First, we used the available human anatomy VR applications from two developers, which may have different image quality of VR. However, both VR applications are comparable in terms of content quality. Second, we have not explored their reasons for high preference for utilising HMD when exploring human anatomy VR, potentially limiting our understanding of the user experience (e.g. comfort, immersion, satisfaction, and overall interaction) related to HMD usage. Third, participants’ previous experience using HMD in other platforms, such as gaming, virtual tours, etc, was not determined. Future studies should consider these limitations to understand user experiences with the HMD platform better and identify factors influencing user preferences.

V. CONCLUSION

In summary, this study concluded that the usability of both HMD and DB in exploring the human anatomy VR application is almost similar. As seen in other studies, students tend to favour HMD over DB because of its immersive, interactive, and engaging features. However, at an individual level, gender may influence their perception of its usability and preference. Therefore, it is essential to take gender-related adaptations into account when developing VR applications. 

Notes on Contributors

Zaitunnatakhin Zamli reviewed the literature, designed the study, performed data collection and analysis, and developed the manuscript. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Nurul Asyiqin Yusof reviewed the literature, designed the study, performed data collection and analysis, and developed the manuscript. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Azmi Mohd Yusof reviewed the literature, designed the study, performed data collection and analysis, and developed the manuscript. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Wan Muhamad Salahudin Wan Salleh designed the study and performed data collection, analysis and interpretation. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Mohd Zulfaezal Che Azemin designed the study and performed data collection, analysis and interpretation. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Rohaini Ramli advised on study design and data interpretation. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Hidayah Sulaiman advised on study design and data interpretation. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Imran Mahalil facilitated the data collection process. The author has read, given critical feedback and approved the final manuscript.

Ethical Approval

Ethical approval of this study was granted by the Kulliyyah Postgraduate and Research Committee (IIUM/305/20/4/1/7) and IIUM Research Ethics Committee (IREC) (IIUM/504/14/11/2/IREC2022-194). All participants involved in the study had given their written consent, and their participation was voluntary.

Data Availability

The data of this study data are available at a Figshare repository, https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.26711965

Acknowledgement

The authors would like to thank the Department of Informatics, College of Computing & Informatics, Universiti Tenaga Nasional, Selangor, Malaysia, for providing equipment, software and logistics support. 

Funding

This study did not receive any funding or financial support.

Declaration of Interest

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

References

Bartlett, K. A., & Camba, J. D. (2023). Gender differences in spatial ability: A critical review. Educational Psychology Review, 35(1), Article 8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-023-09728-2

Deisinger, J., Cruz-Neira, C., Riedel, O., & Symanzik, J. (1997). The effect of different viewing devices for the sense of presence of immersion in virtual environments: A comparison of stereoprojections based on monitors, HMDs and screens. Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Human-Interaction Computer, (2), 881-884. https://www.usu.edu/math/symanzik/papers/1997_HCI_Int.html

Kurul, R., Ögün, M. N., Narin, A. N., Avci, Ş., & Yazgan, B. (2020). An alternative method for anatomy training: Immersive virtual reality. Anatomical Sciences Education, 13(5), 648-656. https://doi.org/10.1002/ase.1959

Stanney, K., Fidopiastis, C., & Foster, L. (2020). Virtual reality is sexist: But it does not have to be. Frontiers in Robotics and AI, 7, 476417 https://doi.org/10.3389/frobt.2020.00004

Yamazaki, A., Ito, T., Sugimoto, M., Yoshida, S., Honda, K., Kawashima, Y., Fujikawa, T., Fujii, Y., & Tsutsumi, T. (2021). Patient-specific virtual and mixed reality for immersive, experiential anatomy education and for surgical planning in temporal bone surgery. Auris Nasus Larynx, 48(6), 1081-1091. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.anl.2021.03.009

*Azmi Mohd. Yusof
Jalan IKRAM-UNITEN,
43000 Kajang,
Selangor, Malaysia
Email: azmiy@uniten.edu.my

Submitted: 17 February 2024
Accepted: 25 March 2025
Published online: 1 July, TAPS 2025, 10(3), 65-74
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/SC3251

Dani R Firman^1,2, Friedo W Dekker^2,3, Eriska Riyanti¹, Sunardhi Widyaputra¹ & Peter GM de Jong²

¹Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Padjadjaran, Indonesia; ²Center for Innovation in Medical Education, Leiden University Medical Center, the Netherlands; ³Department of Clinical Epidemiology, Leiden University Medical Center, the Netherlands

Abstract

Introduction: To explore the current situation regarding teaching evidence-based practice (EBP) in Indonesian dental schools as a low-middle-income country (LMIC) setting.

Methods: Two nation-wide surveys were administered to all Indonesian dental schools (N=32) to capture the perceived value of the deans about EBP skills and teaching with its resource-related situation, as well as the actual teaching implementation and its challenges by their curriculum teams. The analysis was performed descriptively as national aggregate data.

Results: The response rates were 96.9% and 90.6%, respectively. The deans considered EBP skills to be very important (61.3%) or important (38.7%). However, only 16.1% of deans reported that the implementation of teaching EBP met their expectations. Most schools (75.9%) considered providing training for teachers as the priority plan. Most schools (62.1%) had an independent EBP course in their curriculum, while 86.2% incorporated EBP teaching (also) into other courses. All dental schools employed a lecture strategy for teaching EBP topics, but also used other strategies such as interactive strategies with a wide range of percentages being utilised (10.3 – 89.7%). EBP-specific topics were generally taught with a level of implementation varying from 34.5% to 96.6% in the pre-clinical and from 10.3% to 62.1% in the clinical programme.

Conclusion: The used approach can be considered an effective strategy to provide opportunities for schools to reflect their EBP teaching. This study confirmed the necessity for improvement, especially the need to support faculty development. The deans and their curriculum teams highly value collaborative improvement plans.

Keywords:           National Survey, Evidence-based Practice, Faculty Perception, Low-middle-income Country

I. INTRODUCTION

Evidence-based practice (EBP) is emerging as the standard in clinical dentistry. It integrates the best research evidence with patients’ values, preferences, and clinical experiences (Young et al., 2014). The EBP process involves five key steps in sequence (ask, acquire, appraise, apply, and evaluate). The appraise or critical appraisal skill as part of the steps is related to research capacity still considered as crucial gaps in the LMIC setting compared to high-income country (HIC) setting, and known to hinder EBP development and implementation (Gill et al., 2021). Furthermore, the suboptimal practice of EBP among dental professionals in lower and middle-income countries (LMIC) was suspected due to limited access of web-based subscription database and scarcity of experts as mentor (Minja & Lwoga, 2021).

Potentially, dental schools can play a significant role in promoting EBP implementation in dentistry of such setting by providing the access to evidence, supporting professional development and integrate the EBP teaching and learning in the curriculum. However, institutionalising EBP requires consistent policy and strong administrative support. To understand the current situation of EBP teaching in Indonesian dental schools, we conducted a study exploring the deans’ perceptions about its importance and the need for improvement. We also determined the actual level of implementation as reported by their curriculum teams. The study’s outcomes could inform future interventions to enhance EBP teaching in Indonesian dental schools.

II. METHODS

At the time of the study, in September 2022, there were 32 dental schools in Indonesia, all of which ran a bachelor’s programme (year 1-4) and a clinical programme (year 5-6). A descriptive survey study was conducted online using two sets of Indonesian-language questionnaires in sequence.

The first survey was launched during an in-person national meeting in Surabaya. Only the principal investigator himself participated via Zoom. This first survey aimed to gauge deans’ perceived importance of EBP skills and teaching, along with necessary resource improvements. The questionnaire included demographic items, five-point of Likert-scale questions on EBP teaching value, resources-related, an open-ended item on EBP teaching challenges, and a section for additional comments. Most deans completed the first online survey during that meeting, while those who did not attend the meeting were received the survey’s link via email.

Upon completion for each school by the deans, a second survey was sent to vice dean for academic affairs as corresponding contact using the email address provided by the deans in the previous survey. In the introduction letter, we specifically requested the involvement of their curriculum team of the bachelor and clinical programme as a group response for each school. This second survey gathered data on EBP teaching implementation and challenges more in details. It was translated and adapted from a previous survey used by Gorgon et al. (2013) which was considered relevant to all health professions, including dentistry. The adaptation included a pilot test beforehand to ensure its relevance and clarity.

The study protocol was approved by the Educational Research Review Board of the LUMC (Registry number: OEC/ERRB/20220913/1). Participants electronically consented to both surveys after reviewing the provided information. Respondents with missing or unclear data were contacted for clarification. Five-point Likert scale items, checklist items, and multiple-choice items were analysed descriptively. The open-ended item responses and additional comments were analysed thematically.

III. RESULTS

The first survey’s responses were received from 31 dental schools across Indonesia (96.9%). The schools were located on Java (18), Sumatera (6), Sulawesi (3), and Kalimantan and Bali (2 each). For the second survey, which targeted the curriculum team for each school, the responses were received from 29 schools (90.6%).

A. The Perceived Value of EBP Teaching (The 1^st Survey, n=31)

The deans perceived EBP skills as very important/essential (61.3%) or important (38.7%) for students. Incorporating EBP in the curriculum was seen as very important/essential (51.6%) or important (48.4%). Improving teachers’ EBP teaching expertise was deemed very necessary (54.8%) or necessary (38.7%). Five deans (16.1%) felt their schools met faculty expectations for EBP teaching, while others observed room for improvement (64.5% necessary, 19.4% very necessary). Resources like database access and librarian expertise varied in satisfaction. Most respondents (71%) valued collaboration with other schools on EBP training and implementation (See Appendix 1).

B. The Implementation of EBP Teaching (The 2^nd Survey, n=29)

Over half (62.1%) of participated schools have a standalone EBP course, and 86.2% incorporate EBP in other courses. Lecture-based teaching is the most common EBP strategy, followed by thesis discussions, journal readings, colloquiums, and seminars. Small group discussions and problem-based tutorials are also used. “Critically appraised topics” (CATs) are least used, with only three schools employing this active learning method. Both summative and formative assessments are used. Most schools use a blended approach for EBP courses, with one school offering a fully online course (See Appendix 2.a).

C. Available Resources for EBP Teaching (The 1^st and 2^nd Survey, n=31 and n=29)

Of the participating institutions, only 8 out of 29 dental schools have teachers formally-trained in EBP. Most schools have access to scientific databases, with ScienceDirect being the most accessible (58.6%). Other databases include Web of Science, Cochrane Library, EBSCO Host, CINAHL, and UpToDate, with some schools also subscribing to Springer Link, Wiley, Emerald, and SAGE (See Appendix 2.b). Database access is mostly provided by the university (80.6%), with some funded by faculty budgets (29%) or government institutions (9.7%). Only one school lack subscribed database access (See Appendix 3.a).

D. The EBP Specific Topics Coverage (The 2^nd Survey, n=29)

The five EBP steps (ask, acquire, appraise, apply, evaluate) are taught in Indonesian dental schools, with varying implementation levels from 34.5% to 96.6% in pre-clinic programmes and 10.3% to 62.1% in clinic programmes. The ‘apply’ and ‘evaluate’ steps are least taught in pre-clinic programmes. Interpreting forest plots in systematic reviews is the least covered topic, with only 10 out of 29 schools teaching it in pre-clinic levels, 3 in clinical levels, and 19 not covering it at all. Over a third of the schools (37.9%) do not teach critical appraisal of a systematic review. See Table 1 below for details.

	Pre-clinic		Clinic		Not taught in both programme**
EBP steps and its specific topics coverage (n=29)	Taught*	Not taught*	Taught*	Not taught*
I. Asking clinical question
(1) Formulating clinically questions using the PICO format	22 (75.9)	7 (24.1)	12 (41.4)	17 (58.6)	5 (17.2)
(2) Guided literature search by the clinical questions	20 (69.0)	9 (31.0)	18 (62.1)	11 (37.9)	5 (17.2)
II. Search the evidence
(3) Constructing a focused search with Boolean operator in a database	23 (79.3)	6 (20.7)	7 (24.1)	22 (75.9)	6 (20.7)
(4) Locating clinical evidence using electronic databases	26 (89.7)	3 (10.3)	8 (27.6)	21 (72.4)	3 (10.3)
(5) Utilising a reference manager software	25 (86.2)	4 (13.8)	9 (31.0)	20 (69.0)	4 (13.8)
III. Critically appraising evidence
(6) Study designs and their major strength and limitations	27 (93.1)	2 (6.9)	7 (24.1)	22 (75.9)	2 (6.9)
(7) Assessing the relevance of study design to the question asked	22 (75.9)	7 (24.1)	5 (17.2)	24 (82.8)	7 (24.1)
(8) Hierarchy or levels of evidence	23 (79.3)	6 (20.7)	6 (20.7)	23 (79.3)	5 (17.2)
(9) Difference between narrative, systematic review, and meta-analysis	21 (72.4)	8 (27.6)	4 (13.8)	25 (86.2)	7 (24.1)
(10) Difference between clinical and statistical significance	22 (75.9)	7 (24.1)	9 (31.0)	20 (69.0)	6 (20.7)
(11) Interpreting t tests, chi-square tests	28 (96.6)	1 (3.4)	6 (20.7)	23 (79.3)	1 (3.4)
(12) Interpreting p-value, confidence interval	28 (96.6)	1 (3.4)	6 (20.7)	23 (79.3)	1 (3.4)
(13) Understanding sensitivity and specificity, number needed to treat, odds ratio	28 (96.6)	1 (3.4)	6 (20.7)	23 (79.3)	1 (3.4)
(14) Understanding intention to treat analysis and power calculation	20 (69.0)	9 (31.0)	3 (10.3)	26 (89.7)	9 (31.0)
(15) Use of appraisal tool(s) to assess validity	22 (75.9)	7 (24.1)	7 (24.1)	22 (75.9)	7 (24.1)
(16) Ways in which study validity can be threatened	25 (86.2)	4 (13.8)	5 (17.2)	24 (82.8)	4 (13.8)
(17) Difference between internal and external validity	21 (72.4)	8 (27.6)	3 (10.3)	26 (89.7)	8 (27.6)
(18) Critical appraisal of systematic reviews	18 (62.1)	11 (37.9)	6 (20.7)	23 (79.3)	11 (37.9)
(19) Interpreting forest plots in systematic reviews	10 (34.5)	19 (65.5)	3 (10.3)	26 (89.7)	19 (65.5)
(20) Critical appraisal of studies about intervention (RCTs and clinical trials)	18 (62.1)	11 (37.9)	7 (24.1)	22 (75.9)	9 (31.0)
(21) Critical appraisal of studies about diagnosis (cohort, case-control studies)	21 (72.4)	8 (27.6)	5 (17.2)	24 (82.8)	7 (24.1)
(22) Critical appraisal of studies about prognosis (longitudinal studies)	18 (62.1)	11 (37.9)	5 (17.2)	24 (82.8)	10 (34.5)
IV. Implementation and communication
(23) Communicating the recommendation from EBP process to the patient	14 (48.3)	15 (51.7)	9 (31.0)	20 (69.0)	12 (41.4)
(24) Deciding the clinical decision considering the patient’s value	12 (41.4)	17 (58.6)	11 (37.9)	18 (62.1)	11 (37.9)
V. Evaluation
(25) Evaluation of the EBP implementation (The patient’s outcome and student’s performance through self-reflection)	13 (44.8)	16 (55.2)	9 (31.0)	20 (69.0)	13 (44.8)

Table 1. EBP steps and its specific topics coverage for each programme level (n=29)^b

* n (%)

** n (%) Overlap calculation with the number of not taught on each programme

^b From the 2^nd survey to the curriculum teams

E. Challenges (The 1^st Survey, n=31 and The 2^nd Survey, n=29)

The top three challenges in Indonesian dental schools, as reported by curriculum teams, are a lack of EBP experts (72.4%), insufficient accessible EBP courses for faculty (69%), and students’ inadequate knowledge of statistics and research methodology (65.5%) (See appendix 4). In the open-ended item section, most of the deans expressed the challenges of EBP teaching. Teachers-related factors were considered the most challenging, such as limitation in knowledge and skills, and an overloaded work situation.

F. Action Plans (The 2^nd Survey, n=29)

Most respondents (75.9%) highly valued teacher training. They also preferred incorporating EBP skills into the curriculum (48.3%) and holding faculty meetings to discuss EBP programme development (44.8%) (See appendix 3.b).

IV. DISCUSSION

To our knowledge, this is the first nation-wide survey with very high response rate to report insights of EBP teaching in the South-east Asia region, more specifically in Indonesian dental education setting. Targeting both deans and curriculum teams yielded rich data and stakeholder involvement, potentially fostering acceptance of future EBP improvements at institutional or national levels.

There is a slight gap between the perceived importance of EBP skills for students and the importance of incorporating such skills into the curriculum, which may be related to limited resources. The deans considering room for improvement, especially in teacher expertise. This is echoed by curriculum teams, as less than a third of Indonesian dental schools’ teachers have formal training experience, i.e. training from a well-known academic-based institution or recognised training organisation. This lack of EBP teachers is a top challenge identified by respondents. Deans and curriculum teams agree on the need for improved teacher skills.

The majority of Indonesian dental schools are teaching EBP topics in stand-alone EBP courses as well as incorporated in other regular courses using both face-to-face and online delivery. Lecture-based is the most used teaching strategy among the schools. Our findings suggest that there is room for enhancing the teaching strategy of EBP in Indonesian dental schools towards a more multi-facet, interactive and more authentic setting in the clinical environment as suggested by Howard et al. (2022).

Regarding critical appraisal topics based on the study design (See Table 1, item 18, 19-21), there were very few schools implementing a Critically Appraised Topics (CATs) teaching strategy (See Appendix 2.a). CATs, one-page summaries of evidence on a clinical question, offer active, authentic learning and being recommended in the literature to provide both a critique of the research and a statement of the clinical relevance of its findings. It is crucial to teach critical appraisal skills using the teaching strategy that is supported by the evidence to ensure sufficient development of EBP skills. Many Indonesian dental educators may not be familiar with this CATs teaching method.

The survey reveals that the ‘apply’ and ‘evaluate’ steps of EBP are less addressed than the ‘ask’, ‘acquire’, and ‘appraise’ steps. These five-steps, identical to those in Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM), form the basis of clinical practice and teaching. Key EBM developments like shared-decision making skills, part of the ‘apply’ step, are often overlooked. Hence, it’s vital to teach all EBP steps, ideally in a more authentic clinical setting.

The need for more EBP-trained faculty in most schools highlights the importance of a faculty development programme supported by national collaboration. As a lower-resource country, Indonesia faces challenges in dental education, including limited access to databases and librarian expertise, primarily due to financial constraints, inadequate institutional support, and the absence of national policies prioritising scientific resources. These limitations hinder faculty and students from fully implementing evidence-based practices, widening disparities with high-income countries. To address these issues, a policy brief should be directed to high-level stakeholders, advocating for essential infrastructure, more funding and resource investments for both private and government-funded schools.

This study has limitations. Due to the five-point Likert scale in the first questionnaire were not constructed on the same concept, the reliability test was not feasible. This is also applied for the second questionnaire, which adapted from a previous study, was mostly factual and checklist-based. The value of EBP teaching, reported by deans and curriculum teams, might be socially desirable. However, the results underscore the importance of EBP teaching and the need for improvement. It is worth noting that after the data collection was completed, Indonesia formally transitioned from a lower-middle-income to an upper-middle-income country as of July 2023. This transition suggests a more promising future, with potential improvements in the financial capacity, but it will require the national policy support to be fully implemented.

V. CONCLUSION

This first national survey reveals the state of EBP teaching in Indonesian dental schools, representing Southeast Asian countries. It highlights the need for faculty development and more active, authentic learning experiences but further analysis is required to adopt and adapt these interventions for lower-resource settings. The deans and their curriculum teams highly value collaborative improvement plans. This supports EBP’s vision of using current research to improve Indonesian oral healthcare.

Notes on Contributors

DF is the principal investigator. He designed, analysed, prepared and wrote the manuscript collaboratively with co-authors.

SW and ER made substantial contributions to preparation of the instruments, data collection and editing the final manuscript.

FD and PJ made substantial contribution to the design, analysis, preparation and editing the final manuscript.

All authors read and approved the final version.

Ethical Approval

The study protocol was approved by the Educational Research Review Board of the LUMC (Registry number: OEC/ERRB/20220913/1).

Data Availability

Due to confidentiality of the responses and commitments made with the study participants, also considering the small size data set with its unique data for some variables that might still be traceable to the respondent. Data are available on reasonable request by email to the corresponding author.

Acknowledgement

The authors express gratitude to all participants and schools involved in this study, AFDOKGI and its members for their support and data access, the Research group at the OEC LUMC for their constructive feedback, Universitas Padjadjaran for sponsoring the first author’s PhD scholarship, and Edward Gorgon for permitting the modification and use of the questionnaire.

Funding

This research is part of the first author’s (DF) PhD study, funded by a scholarship from Universitas Padjadjaran, Indonesia (Registry number 3781/UN.6.WR2/KP.10/2021).

Declaration of Interest

The first author (DF), an assistant professor at the Faculty of Dentistry, Universitas Padjadjaran, which participated in this study. DF also had ties until 2020 with AFDOKGI, the association of Indonesian dental schools, as a dental education consultant. 

References

Gill, P. J., Ali, S. M., Elsobky, Y., Okechukwu, R. C., Ribeiro, T. B., Soares dos Santos Junior, A. C., Umpierre, D., & Richards, G. C. (2021). Building capacity in evidence-based medicine in low-income and middle-income countries: Problems and potential solutions. BMJ Evidence-Based Medicine, 26(3), 82–84. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjebm-2019-111272

Gorgon, E. J. R., Basco, M. D. S., & Manuel, A. T. (2013). Teaching evidence-based practice in physical therapy in a developing country: A national survey of Philippine schools. BMC Medical Education, 13(1), Article 154. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6920-13-154

Howard, B., Diug, B., & Ilic, D. (2022). Methods of teaching evidence-based practice: A systematic review. BMC Medical Education, 22(1), Article 742. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-022-03812-x

Minja, I. K., & Lwoga, E. T. (2021). Evidence based dentistry among dentists in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic review. The East African Health Research Journal, 5(2), 129–136. https://doi.org/10.24248/eahrj.v5i2.662

Young, T., Rohwer, A., Volmink, J., & Clarke, M. (2014). What are the effects of teaching evidence-based health care (EBHC)? Overview of systematic reviews. PLOS ONE, 9(1), e86706. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0086706

*Dani R Firman
Jalan Sekeloa Selatan I,
Kota Bandung, Jawa Barat 40132,
Indonesia
+62222534985
Email: dani.firman@unpad.ac.id / d.r.firman@lumc.nl

Submitted: 6 November 2024
Accepted: 11 April 2025
Published online: 1 July, TAPS 2025, 10(3), 58-64
https://doi.org/10.29060/TAPS.2025-10-3/OA3567

Nathania Nishida Tan¹, Daniel Ardian Soeselo^2,3, Natalia Puspadewi², V. Dwi Jani Juliawati² & Gisella Anastasia²

¹Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia, Indonesia;  ²Medical Education Unit and ³Department of Surgery, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia, Indonesia

Abstract

Introduction: Career selection is a critical decision influenced by various factors, including media exposure. As a popular genre among adolescents, medical dramas may shape perceptions of the medical profession. This study explores the impact of medical dramas on medical students’ motivation to pursue a career in medicine.

Methods: This study was conducted at the School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia, between February and March 2024, using a mixed-method approach. Quantitative data were gathered through a questionnaire, followed by qualitative insights from in-depth interviews. A two-stage sampling strategy was employed, initially identifying first-year students influenced by medical dramas through screening, followed by purposive sampling to select participants for in-depth interviews.

Results: Analysis identified six key motivational aspects through which medical dramas influence students’ decision to pursue medicine. These include the detailed portrayal of doctors’ roles, their daily lives, and the reinforcement of a positive perception of the profession. Notably, emotional engagement- such as inspiring doctor characters- and the realistic depiction of challenges, including the dedication and hardships of becoming a doctor, emerged as significant factors.

Conclusion: Medical dramas play a significant role in shaping students’ motivation and perception of the medical profession. This study highlights six key motivational aspects influencing career decisions, offering new insights into media-driven career choices and their potential implications for medical education.

Keywords:           Medical Dramas, Medical Education, Medical Students, Student Motivation, Career Choice

Practice Highlights

• Medical dramas serve as informal educational tools through entertainment for the public.
• Television influences adolescents’ career aspirations by shaping their interests.
• Medical dramas shape public perceptions of the medical profession and may inspire viewers.

I. INTRODUCTION

Medical dramas have remained a widely popular television genre since their emergence in the 1960s, continuously evolving to portray healthcare professionals’ professional and personal lives within hospital settings (14^th Media Mutations International Conference, 2023; Sonego & Rocchi, 2024).

Communication theorist Marshall McLuhan had predicted the success of medical dramas as early as 1964 in his book Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man, attributing their appeal to the immersive experience viewers have when witnessing medical procedures, which fosters an “obsession with bodily well-being” (Aboud, 2012; Levine & McLuhan, 1964).

Beyond entertainment, medical dramas serve as informal educational tools illustrating medical practices, bioethical dilemmas, and professional conduct (Cambra-Badii et al., 2021; Zago et al., 2024). Research suggests that these dramas reinforce key principles of medical ethics and professionalism, including communication skills, patient confidentiality, and empathetic bedside manner (Aboud, 2012). By portraying both the challenges and rewards of medical practice, these narratives may also shape viewers’ perceptions of the profession, inspiring people to pursue careers in healthcare (Alahmari, 2023).

Research indicates a correlation between specific television programs and career aspirations, suggesting that the content adolescents consume can shape vocational interests and goals (Gehrau et al., 2016). As an accessible informal educational resource, television provides insight into professional responsibilities and challenges (Mendick & Williams, 2022). Within this context, medical dramas may play a significant role in shaping students’ motivation to enter the medical field. Unlike prior studies that broadly examine media influence over career perceptions, this study focuses on first-year medical students, analysing their motivational drive. By integrating quantitative and qualitative data, this study provides deeper insight into how medical dramas influence medical students’ motivation to pursue a career in medicine.  

II. METHODS

This study was conducted at the School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia, from February to March 2024, using a mixed-method approach. A two-stage sampling method was employed, beginning with a questionnaire to identify eligible participants, followed by purposive sampling to select individuals for in-depth interviews. The target population consisted of first-year medical students enrolled in the 2023 academic year who acknowledged that medical dramas had influenced their motivation to pursue a medical degree.

A. Participant Selection

Out of 210 first-year students, 114 reported watching medical dramas. These students completed a demographic questionnaire, which gathered information on gender, parents’ profession, and their viewing habits related to medical dramas. Additionally, they completed the Strength of Motivation for Medical School Revised (SMMS-R) Questionnaire, a validated self-report instrument consisting of 15 items rated on a 5-point Likert scale (ranging from “strongly disagree” to “strongly agree”), with possible scores ranging from 15 to 75, indicating the strength of motivation for medical school.

B. Qualitative Phase Sampling

Purposive sampling was used to ensure an accurate representation of the study population based on key demographic factors, specifically the profession of participants’ parents. The selection process identified respondents from diverse parental backgrounds in the medical field: those with both parents as physicians, those with one parent in medicine, and those with no parental medical background. To ensure gender diversity, one male and one female were selected from each category, all of whom had high motivation scores based on their SMMS-R results. Six participants were selected to achieve thematic saturation, as preliminary analysis showed no new themes emerging beyond this point. Although not statistically representative, this sample captures diverse perspectives on medical career motivation based on different childhood backgrounds.

C. Data Collection

The in-depth interviews, conducted by the researcher (NNT), explored participants’ perceptions of how medical dramas influenced their motivation to pursue a career in medicine. The interview guide addressed various aspects of this influence on their decision-making process. One key question asked was “How have medical dramas influenced your decision to pursue medicine?” All participants provided written informed consent, including permission for audio recording. The interviews were then transcribed verbatim for further analysis.

D. Data Analysis

The transcribed interviews were analysed using thematic analysis with an inductive coding approach, facilitated by Atlas.Ti software. Initial coding was conducted by NNT, who identified key patterns and concepts. These were then systematically categorised into themes and subthemes to capture broader meanings and insights emerging from the interviews. To ensure coding reliability, DAS and NP reviewed the preliminary codes and analysis results. Through thorough discussions and iterative revisions, the team resolved discrepancies and achieved near-total agreement on the coding structure. To maintain participant confidentiality, each transcript was assigned a unique identification code. 

III. RESULTS

A total of 114 respondents participated in this study, consisting of 26 males and 88 females, reflecting a possible gender disparity in medical drama viewership. Among them, 93 students (81.6%) reported that medical dramas significantly impacted their decision to pursue a medical career, while 21 students indicated no such impact.

Characteristic		Respondents (n)	Percentage (%)
Parental Background
	Both parents are doctors	8	7.0
	Only one parent is a doctor	18	15.8
	Neither parent is a doctor	88	77.2
Reports Motivation to Enter Medical Field Due to Medical Dramas
	Yes	93	81.6
	No	21	18.4
	Total Respondents	114	100.0

Table 1. Distribution of Respondent Demographic Characteristics

A. Various Dimensions of the Impact of Medical Dramas on Motivation

The following table presents the themes and subthemes derived from the in-depth interview analysis, which has been discussed and approved by each inter-rater.

No.	Theme	Subtheme
1.	Medical dramas provide an in-depth portrayal of the roles and responsibilities of doctors.	Medical dramas shape public perceptions of the medical profession and doctors’ roles.
		Medical dramas depict the challenges and rewards of doctors’ daily work.
		Medical dramas highlight doctors’ lives beyond their profession.
2.	Medical dramas depict both the professional and personal aspects of doctors’ lives.	Medical dramas reveal lesser-known aspects of doctors’ personal experiences.
		Medical dramas provide an authentic portrayal of doctors’ daily lives.
		Medical dramas depict ethical dilemmas, emphasising doctors’ professional integrity.
3.	Medical dramas contribute to a positive public perception of the medical profession.	Medical dramas portray impressive doctors, evoking admiration, and inspiration in viewers.
		Doctors’ life-saving actions in medical dramas evoke deep emotions and motivation.
		Medical dramas illustrate doctors’ perseverance and resilience in their profession.
		Medical dramas spark curiosity about medical procedures and treatments.
4.	Medical dramas evoke emotional responses that may inspire viewers to pursue a medical career.	Medical dramas evoke empathy by portraying patients in distress.
5.	Medical dramas showcase inspiring doctor characters, motivating viewers to follow in their footsteps.
6.	Medical dramas illustrate the challenges and dedication required to become a doctor.

Table 2. Table of Themes and Subthemes

B. Medical Dramas Provide an In-Depth Portrayal of the Roles and Responsibilities of Doctors

Medical dramas frequently portray various medical scenarios using specialised terminology, offering viewers insight into the daily responsibilities of doctors. As medical settings are generally inaccessible to the public, these dramas provide a unique perspective on the profession. Among the key influences explored in this study, this aspect resonated most with respondents, with four out of six students emphasising its significance.

One participant explained how watching medical dramas sparked their interest in the field, as they previously had limited information about medicine.

“Grey’s Anatomy offered me insight into the medical field and sparked my interest, as reliable information is not easily accessible to those outside the profession” (V1_H3_B19)

Another respondent shared how their perception of doctors shifted from fear to admiration after watching medical dramas, recognising the profession’s vital role in society:

“As a child, I perceived doctors as intimidating due to painful medical visits, such as dental appointments. However, after watching Grey’s Anatomy, I realised that medicine extends beyond that and saw how doctors can positively impact many lives.” (V1_H2_B27)

Beyond hospital settings, medical dramas also depict the role of doctors in broader societal contexts. Through diverse narratives, these dramas offer multiple perspectives on the medical profession. For example, Doc Martin illustrates the role of a doctor in a rural community, showcasing their involvement in local issues, such as water problems and education (V2_H4_B21). This highlights how doctors contribute beyond clinical practice, reinforcing their role in public health and community development.

Additionally, medical dramas influence students’ motivation to pursue medicine by portraying the realities of medical work, including complex procedures and life-saving interventions. More than half of the respondents identified this as a significant factor in their decision to study medicine. As one participant stated:

“The scenes depicting doctors helping others, particularly during surgeries, inspired me to study medicine. I wanted to experience performing surgeries and learn how to help others.” (V4_H7_B19)

These findings suggest that medical dramas not only enhance public understanding of the profession but also play a role in inspiring future medical students.

C. Medical Dramas Depict Both the Professional and Personal Aspects of Doctors’ Lives

Medical dramas depict not only medical procedures but also the personal lives of doctors, including their relationships, friendships, and personal struggles. By presenting doctors as multidimensional individuals beyond their professional roles, these narratives contribute to a more relatable and humanised portrayal of the profession. Notably, four out of six highlighted the importance of this aspect in shaping their motivation. One respondent noted that their interest in medical dramas stemmed primarily from the blend of romantic elements, rather than the medical content alone (V3_H6_B1).

The public often has limited insight into the personal experiences of doctors, making it difficult to relate to them. However, medical dramas help bridge this gap by shedding light on aspects of doctors’ lives that are not commonly shared. This increased visibility fosters a sense of closeness and enhances a deeper understanding of the profession, which may, in turn, inspire career interest. As one participant expressed:

“Medical dramas reveal stories that doctors seldom share, providing an effective way to convey these experiences to the general public.” (V5_H11_B4)

By offering a representation of doctors’ daily lives, medical dramas provide viewers with a deeper understanding of what a career in medicine entails. This additional perspective can be a key factor in the decision-making process for those considering entering the field (V2_H4_B28).

D. Medical Dramas Contribute to a Positive Public Perception of the Medical Profession

Three out of six respondents emphasised that medical dramas portray the ethical dilemmas faced by doctors, reinforcing professional values that shape viewers’ perceptions of the medical field. One respondent noted that the depiction of doctors’ strong work ethic in these dramas increased their interest in pursuing a career in medicine (V3_H6_B4).

Additionally, medical dramas present compelling and admirable doctor characters, which can serve as a source of inspiration for viewers. As one respondent shared:

“The dramatised portrayal made it inspiring for my younger self, leading me to think, ‘Doctors are cool.’” (V5_H11_B2)

The depiction of medical procedures, particularly surgeries, also left a strong impression on some respondents, reinforcing their motivation to enter the medical field. One participant stated:

“Medical dramas provide insight into a doctor’s work, including various surgeries, highlighting the fascinating ability to help many people.”  (V4_H7_B33)

Furthermore, the portrayal of doctors saving lives in medical dramas can evoke strong emotional responses, fostering admiration and a desire to pursue medicine. One respondent expressed how these scenes encouraged them to consider a career in medicine (V5_H11_B2). Medical dramas also emphasise the perseverance and resilience of doctors in the face of various pressures and stress, further reinforcing the appeal of the profession for aspiring medical students (V5_H9_B11).

E. Medical Dramas Evoke Emotional Responses that may Inspire Viewers to Pursue a Medical Career

Medical dramas can spark viewers’ curiosity about medical procedures, motivating them to explore the medical field further and increase their interest in the profession. One respondent noted that medical dramas played a role in their initial motivation for pursuing medicine, as the cases depicted often align with real-world medical scenarios, piquing their interest to learn more:

“I believe the medical procedures shown in Grey’s Anatomy exist in real life and are up to date. For example, an episode featured an abdominal wall transplant, which piqued my curiosity. After researching it, I discovered that the procedure had only recently been developed, showing how the show connects to world medicine.” (V1_H2_B14)

Beyond fostering curiosity, medical dramas also evoke strong emotional responses, such as sadness and empathy, particularly when portraying patients in need of medical care. One respondent shared that such portrayals heightened their awareness of the number of people requiring medical assistance. The emotions they experienced, combined with this awareness, ultimately served as an inspiration to pursue medicine (V1_H2_B31).

F. Medical Dramas Showcase Inspiring Doctor Characters, Motivating Viewers to Follow in their Footsteps

Medical dramas can inspire viewers through uplifting scenes and compelling portrayals of doctor characters. These representations serve as role models, fostering admiration and desire to follow in their footsteps. Notably, three out of six respondents indicated that such portrayals influenced their decision to pursue a medical career. As one participant shared:

“In ‘New Amsterdam’, there is a doctor who stands out from others – someone who wants to create change and has a unique vision. I found him quite inspiring.” (V3_H6_B5)

G. Medical Dramas Illustrate the Challenges and Dedication Required to Become a Doctor

Medical dramas not only portray the professional responsibilities of doctors but also illustrate the journey of becoming one, highlighting the challenges and obstacles along the way. Two out of six students emphasised the significance of this theme, noting that the depiction of medical interns’ experience in these dramas played a crucial role in their motivation to pursue medicine. As one participant shared:

“Medical dramas often depict doctors under immense stress, highlighting the challenges of the profession. However, rather than discouraging me, witnessing their struggles made the career even more appealing.” (V5_H10_B28)

IV. DISCUSSION

The in-depth interviews revealed that medical students felt more mentally prepared and motivated to pursue medicine after watching medical dramas. These shows provided insight into both the professional and personal lives of doctors, reinforcing previous studies on their educational influence in shaping viewers’ perceptions of the medical field. This aligns with the Media Effect Theory, introduced by Gerbner in 1960, which suggests that television shapes individuals’ perceptions of reality, particularly among frequent viewers (Stacks et al., 2015). Hoffman and colleagues further applied this theory to medical dramas, highlighting their role in influencing viewers’ perception of the medical profession (Arias, 2018).

Beyond depicting technical medical procedures, medical dramas also emphasise ethical principles and professional values, contributing to a favourable image of the profession. Research indicates that medical and nursing students often use these shows as supplementary learning tools for bioethics and professionalism (Cambra-Badii et al., 2021). Similarly, these portrayals may inspire high school students to consider careers in medicine by offering an engaging introduction to the field.

Emotional engagement is another key factor in the influence of medical dramas. Strong emotional responses- such as curiosity, empathy, and excitement- can enhance motivation, as emotions play a crucial role in learning, achievement, and psychological well-being, particularly in adolescents (Pekrun, 2017). Positive emotions make tasks more appealing, fostering inner motivation that arises after the initial external excitement provided by medical dramas (Legault, 2016).

Furthermore, medical dramas often depict the challenges of medical training, including long working hours and emotional strain, providing a more nuanced perspective on the profession. While these portrayals may initially present an idealised view of medicine, they also serve as a reality check, reinforcing the dedication required to pursue a medical career. This dual representation may deter less committed individuals while strengthening the resolve of those deeply passionate about the field (Tedeschi, 2024).

However, the potential for misinformation in medical dramas must also be considered. The oversimplifications or dramatisation of medical practice may create discrepancies between fictional portrayals and real-world medicine, leading to misconceptions among viewers (Alismail et al., 2018).  One notable bias is the tendency to depict doctors as infallible heroes performing miraculous saves amidst dramatic emergencies, often intertwined with personal achievements and romantic subplots. This portrayal fosters unrealistic expectations, potentially leading to disillusionment when aspiring medical students encounter the demanding and less glamorous realities of medical education and practice (Tedeschi, 2024).

These findings highlight the complex role of medical dramas in shaping career motivation, offering both inspiration and potential misconceptions. Their influence appears particularly significant for students without a familial background in medicine, as most respondents came from non-medical families. This trend may suggest that medical dramas serve as an accessible source of insight into the profession for those without direct exposure. However, the possibility of sampling bias should be considered, as students already interested in medicine may be more likely to engage in medical dramas. While these dramas may serve as informal educational tools, their impact should be critically assessed to ensure they provide a balanced and realistic portrayal of the medical profession.

V. CONCLUSION

Medical dramas play a significant role in shaping students’ motivation to pursue a medical career by providing an engaging portrayal of the profession. These shows offer insight into the roles and responsibilities of doctors, their daily challenges, and the emotional rewards of the profession. Additionally, they influence public perceptions of medicine and evoke strong emotional responses through inspiring characters and narratives. By depicting both the struggles and triumphs of medical training, medical dramas contribute to students’ understanding of the dedication required to become a doctor. This study highlights six key aspects through which medical dramas impact students’ decision to pursue medical education, highlighting their role as both an informational and motivational tool.

Notes on Contributors

Nathania Nishida Tan participated in data collection, data analysis, review, the writing of the paper, and the formatting for publication.

dr. Daniel Ardian Soeselo, Sp.B, MSi.Med. participated in the data analysis, review, and direction of the paper.

dr. Natalia Puspadewi, M.Med.Ed, Ph.D participated in the data analysis, review, and direction of the paper.

dr. Gisella Anastasia, MHPE participated in the review of the paper.

dr. V. Dwi Jani Juliawati, M.PD, Sp.KKLP participated in the review of the paper.

Ethical Approval

This study received ethical clearance from the Research Ethics Commission of the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia under the ethical approval code 13/02/KEP-FKIKUAJ/2024. To ensure confidentiality and data security, all interview transcripts were anonymised and securely stored in password-protected files, accessible only to the research team.

Data Availability

The data of this qualitative study are not publicly available due to confidentiality agreements with the participants.

Acknowledgement

The authors would like to thank all the students who participated in this study.

Funding

There was no funding for this article.

Declaration of Interest

The authors have no conflicts of interest in connection with this article.

References

Aboud, K. A. (2012). Medical dramas – The pros and the cons. Dermatology Practical & Conceptual, 2(1), 75–77. https://doi.org/10.5826/dpc.0201a14

Alahmari, A. A. (2023). Professionalism, ethics, and realism of television medical dramas as perceived by Saudi medical students. Journal of Medical Education and Curricular Development, 10. https://doi.org/10.1177/23821205231175037

Alismail, A., Meyer, N. C., Almutairi, W., & Daher, N. S. (2018). CPR in medical TV shows: Non-health care student perspective. Advances in Medical Education and Practice, 9, 85–91. https://doi.org/10.2147/AMEP.S146149

Arias, E. (2018). How does media influence social norms? Experimental evidence on the role of common knowledge. Political Science Research and Methods, 7(3), 561–578. https://doi.org/10.1017/psrm.2018.1

Cambra-Badii, I., Moyano, E., Ortega, I., Baños, J., & Sentí, M. (2021). TV medical dramas: Health sciences students’ viewing habits and potential for teaching issues related to bioethics and professionalism. BMC Medical Education, 21, Article 509. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-021-02947-7

Gehrau, V., Brüggemann, T., & Handrup, J. (2016). Media and occupational aspirations: The effect of television on career aspirations of adolescents. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 60(3), 465–483. https://doi.org/10.1080/08838151.2016.1203319

14^th Media Mutations International Conference. (2023). Investigating medical drama TV series: Approaches and perspectives.

Legault, L. (2016). Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Springer eBooks. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-28099-8_1139-1

Levine, S., & McLuhan, M. (1964). Understanding media: The extensions of man. American Quarterly, 16(4), 646. https://doi.org/10.2307/2711172

Mendick, H., & Williams, K. (2022). Does television influence young people’s career choices? Journal of the National Institute for Career Education and Counselling, 21(1), 18–22. https://doi.org/10.20856/jnicec.2103

Pekrun, R. (2017). Emotion and achievement during adolescence. Child Development Perspectives, 11(3), 215–221. https://doi.org/10.1111/cdep.12237

Sonego, A., & Rocchi, M. (2024). Medical drama TV series: A semi-systematic literature review. Online Journal of Communication and Media Technologies, 14(4), Article e202459. https://doi.org/10.30935/ojcmt/15268

Stacks, D. W., Li, Z. C., & Spaulding, C. (2015). Media effects. Elsevier eBooks. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-0970868.95045-1

Tedeschi, R. (2024). The paradox of medical dramas: Global aspirations versus realities. BJPsych Advances, 31(1), 62–64. https://doi.org/10.1192/bja.2024.56

Zago, D., Cautero, P., Scarpis, E., Pompili, E., Voglino, G., Siliquini, R., Brusaferro, S., & Brunelli, L. (2024). TV medical dramas: Assessing the portrayal of public health in primetime. Frontiers in Public Health, 12. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2024.1432528

*Daniel Ardian Soeselo
Medical Education Unit and Department of Surgery,
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences,
Atma Jaya Catholic University of Indonesia
Jl. Pluit Raya No.2 21, RT.21/RW.8,
Penjaringan, Kec. Penjaringan, Jakarta Utara,
Daerah Khusus Ibukota Jakarta, Indonesia 14440
Email: daniel.ardian@atmajaya.ac.id